August 2019Cryptocurrency: A Primer for Policy-MakersZack Gold and Megan McBrideApproved for public release. Unlimited distribution.CRM-2019-U-020185-Final
AbstractThis primer is an effort to address a gap in knowledge about cryptocurrencies and the cryptocurrency ecosystemamong the policymaking community and advance the understanding of cryptocurrencies and consideration of theirnational security implications. Cryptocurrencies are strictly digital currencies, are typically overseen by adecentralized peer-to-peer community, and are secured through cryptography. We use clear, non-technical languageto describe complex concepts and demystify overly technical terms in order to explain the technical and economicaspects of cryptocurrency, why they are used, and the benefits and drawbacks to cryptocurrencies compared toconventional currencies—like the US dollar. We conclude by considering some cryptocurrency-related issues of whichgreater exploration would benefit US national security.This document contains the best opinion of CNA at the time of issue.It does not necessarily represent the opinion of the sponsor or client.DistributionApproved for public release. Unlimited distribution.Cover image credit: “Photo of a mobile phone with a Bitcoin Cash wallet, Bitcoin whitepaper by SatoshiNakamoto and Bitcoin.com pen.” BitcoinXio, Apr. 15, 2018.Approved by:August 2019Jonathan Schroden, Research Program DirectorSpecial Operations ProgramCenter for Stability & DevelopmentStrategy, Policy, Plans, and Programs Division (SP3)Request additional copies of this document through [email protected] 2019 CNA. All rights reserved
Executive SummaryIn 2017, the value of one Bitcoin skyrocketed to more than 20,000. Media coverage increased,and even people who did not join the investment frenzy became aware of so-called“cryptocurrencies.” Despite this familiarity, few actually understand cryptocurrencies and theimplications they may have on US interests, from global finance to national security to goodgovernance.Cryptocurrencies are strictly digital currencies (and not merely the digital exchange ofconventional currencies such as US dollars), are typically overseen by a decentralized peer-topeer community, and are secured through cryptography. Cryptocurrency supporters highlightthe potential for cryptocurrencies to improve buyer-seller transactions. Meanwhile, newsreports over the past decade have raised red flags about the use of this technology by criminals,terrorists, and rogue states.CNA initiated this study to explore the implications of cryptocurrencies for special operationsforces (SOF), the broader US Department of Defense (DOD), and other US government agencies.In the process of considering national security implications, we found a gap in knowledge aboutcryptocurrencies and the cryptocurrency ecosystem among the policy-making community.This primer is an effort to address that gap and advance the understanding of cryptocurrenciesand consideration of their national security implications.Cryptocurrencies differ from most conventional currencies in five significant ways:1. Cryptocurrencies are not controlled or regulated by banks or governments.2. Cryptocurrencies rely on a decentralized system (known as the “blockchain”).3. Cryptocurrency exchange rates can be extremely volatile.4. Cryptocurrencies typically have longer transaction times.5. Cryptocurrency transactions are pseudonymous 1 or anonymous.1The individual conducting the transaction is known, but his or her true identity may be unknown.CNA Research Memorandum i
Figure:What is a blockchain?A blockchain is an immutable decentralized ledger: Immutable — each new block essentially locks inprevious blocks Decentralized — a peer-to-peer network of computerizedcontributors creates new blocks Ledger — a list (i.e., a chain) of individual records (i.e.,blocks)For more information on blockchains, see the section“Cryptocurrencies as technology.”Source: CNA.Cryptocurrencies (Bitcoin being the first and most popular) were developed to solve theproblem of buyers cheating sellers (through a currency problem called “double-spending”)without introducing someone to oversee the transaction (a third-party authority). Bitcoin’screators addressed this issue through cryptographic problem-solving (called “mining”)conducted by a decentralized, computerized network.Cryptocurrency use is still far from mainstream, but using cryptocurrencies for transactionshas potential benefits. First, cryptocurrencies provide secure transactions without needing toplace trust in the third-party authority of banks. Second, cryptocurrencies can be acceptedglobally, so goods and services could be purchased anywhere in the world without having tofirst exchange payment into local currency. Third, similar to cash purchases, cryptocurrencytransactions do not require participants to provide identification; however, moving large sumsof cryptocurrencies is much easier than moving bulk cash. Fourth, unlike brick-and-mortarbanks and exchange houses—where cash transactions take place—cryptocurrencytransactions are processed around the clock.However, cryptocurrencies also suffer from weaknesses. Some vulnerabilities are built into thevery systems of cryptocurrency and the blockchain, such as exchange rate volatility, lengthytransaction times, and the potential that the system could be hijacked. Additionally, hackershave stolen cryptocurrencies numerous times.It is worth keeping in mind that the relative benefits of cryptocurrencies over conventionalcurrencies increase in developing and under-developed countries and in nations with poorfiscal and monetary management. For example, if local conventional currencies suffer fromhigh exchange rate volatility, the swings of cryptocurrency values may be less concerning.CNA Research Memorandum ii
Using cryptocurrencies also has relative benefits for those who engage in illicit activity. In ourcompanion paper, we explore cryptocurrency issues for SOF. Although written with a SOFaudience in mind, that report may also be of interest to a broader policy audience because itincludes: (1) a detailed taxonomy and examples of nefarious activities involvingcryptocurrencies, such as funding terrorist activity, money laundering, cybercrimes, andregulatory crimes; (2) a discussion of state-actor engagement in the cryptocurrency arena thatexplores Iranian, North Korean, Russian, and Venezuelan activity in skirting sanctions, miningcryptocurrencies, participating in exchange hacking and ransomware, and usingcryptocurrencies to fund information operations; and (3) analysis attempting to anticipate themid-term future of the cryptocurrency ecosystem.Our companion paper ends by highlighting the tactical and strategic challenges andopportunities of cryptocurrencies for SOF. Written for a broader audience, this primerconcludes by considering some other cryptocurrency-related issues of which greaterexploration would benefit US national security.These areas include the following challenges: Safe havens for illicit actors. Transnational criminal organizations and other illicitactors can take advantage of gaps in international regulations of cryptocurrencies tooperate freely in countries with lax oversight.Sanctions evasion. Internationally sanctioned regimes, such as North Korea,purchase, mine, or steal cryptocurrencies to raise funds. Venezuela attempted toaccess foreign investment by launching its own cryptocurrency, the petro.Speed of technological adaptation. The adoption of new and constantly evolvingcryptocurrency technologies can hinder efforts developed by law enforcement and theintelligence community to track illicit activity.And opportunities: Protection of free speech. Actors can use cryptocurrencies to raise funds and spreadtheir message outside traditional internet platforms and services (e.g., when theinternet is government or private-industry censored).Good governance. Just as the blockchain secures a cryptocurrency, it has thepotential to secure and legitimize functions of governance.Cryptocurrencies and the technologies related to them are innovative financial tools withimplications for national security. We hope this paper—in which we use clear, non-technicallanguage to describe complex concepts and demystify overly technical terms—will help the USgovernment more effectively support legitimate cryptocurrency users and counter illicit ones.CNA Research Memorandum iii
This page intentionally left blank.CNA Research Memorandum iv
ContentsIntroduction. 1What Are Cryptocurrencies?. 3Why were cryptocurrencies created? . 4Double-spending. 5Third-party trust. 6The birth of Bitcoin . 6How Do Cryptocurrencies Work?. 10Cryptocurrencies as technology . 10Mining . 10Transactions . 11Cryptocurrencies as currencies . 14Volatility and transaction times . 14Using cryptocurrencies . 19Obtaining and exchanging cryptocurrencies . 19Holding cryptocurrencies . 21Spending cryptocurrencies . 22Investing in cryptocurrencies . 23Regulating cryptocurrencies . 24An Assessment of Cryptocurrencies: Weaknesses and Common Myths .27Weaknesses of cryptocurrencies . 27Common myths about cryptocurrencies . 30The myth of anonymity . 30The myth of immutability . 33The myth of a trustless system . 33Cryptocurrency Issues for Policy-Makers . 35Challenges in countering illicit activities . 35Regulation gaps create safe-havens for illicit actors . 35Individuals, entities, and states moving to cryptocurrency to evade sanctions. 36Cyberspace is adapting faster than law enforcement techniques . 37Opportunities for supporting free speech and good governance . 38Blockchain immutability can protect free speech. 38Potential impacts of blockchain technology on governance . 39Conclusion . 42Figures . 43CNA Research Memorandum v
Tables . 44Abbreviations . 45References . 46CNA Research Memorandum vi
IntroductionIn 2017, the value of one Bitcoin skyrocketed to more than 20,000. During that boom, millionsof people around the world joined the virtual gold rush by investing in Bitcoin (the first andmost popular cryptocurrency), competitor cryptocurrencies, or the blockchain technologyunderlying the innovation. Media coverage increased, and even people who did not join thefrenzy heard the words “Bitcoin,” “cryptocurrencies,” and “blockchain.” In fact, awareness ofBitcoin has risen rapidly since its 2008 launch. By 2018, nearly 80 percent of Americansreported having heard the term “Bitcoin.” 1 Despite this familiarity, few actually understandthese technologies and the implications they may have on US interests, from global finance tonational security to good governance.The US Department of Defense (DOD), like the general public, is aware of cryptocurrencies butstill lacks a thorough understanding. To fill this knowledge gap, in May 2018, the Joint SpecialOperations University (JSOU) asked for research on the topic, “The evolution ofcryptocurrency: Future challenges and opportunities for SOF” (special operations forces). 2CNA initiated this study to explore the cryptocurrency ecosystem and help SOF consider theimplications of cryptocurrencies on SOF missions, including counter-threat finance.In the process of researching and writing Cryptocurrency: Implications for Special OperationsForces, which we published concurrently with this paper, we realized that—with the exceptionof some pockets of expertise—few US military and government personnel were working in thefield of cryptocurrencies. Indeed, we identified a gap in knowledge of cryptocurrencies amongthe US policy and decision-making community. We recognized that a simple primer aimed at anational security policy audience would be of value and produced this paper accordingly.A cryptocurrency expert will find this primer simplistic: that was our intention. Our goal wasto explain key cryptocurrency terms, technologies, and applications in easy-to-followNikhilesh De, “Survey: Nearly 80% of Americans Have Heard of Bitcoin,” Coindesk, Sept. 6, americans-have-heard-of-bitcoin.1Joint Special Operations University, Special Operations Research Topics 2018 (Revised Edition ),https://jsou.libguides.com/ld.php?content id 41898487.2CNA Research Memorandum 1
language—with many figures and examples. What makes our primer different from the dozensof cryptocurrency explainers on the internet is our attention to issues with policy and nationalsecurity implications.This primer does not attempt to explain comprehensively the nuanced intricacies ofcryptocurrencies in technical and financial detail. Nor does it explore the far-reaching potentialimplications of blockchain technology, one of which—logistics—is discussed in CNA’s 2018occasional paper, “Leveraging Blockchain to Secure Logistics Information.” 3 Instead, weexplain the core issues that are necessary to understand the basics of cryptocurrency (in termsof technology and economics).The rest of this primer is organized into three main sections. The first section provides a briefhistory of cryptocurrencies and the problems inherent in digital currencies (indeed, in allcurrencies) that cryptography aspires to solve. The second section, which makes up the bulkof the primer, explains how cryptocurrencies work. We discuss the technology ofcryptocurrencies; the difference between cryptocurrencies and conventional currencies; andhow users obtain, hold, and exchange cryptocurrencies. The third section recommends areasin which more research and analysis are required on the impact of cryptocurrencies. Theseissues should be considered in addition to the cryptocurrency implications for SOF, which weexplore in our companion report. Our goal is that this primer will contribute to theunderstanding of cryptocurrencies among the policy-making community and build knowledgeof the implications of this innovative technology on US national security.Readers that already understand the basics of cryptocurrencies or that are interested in theimpact of cryptocurrency on national security are encouraged to read our companion paper.Although written with a SOF audience in mind, that report highlights examples of states andnon-state actors using cryptocurrencies for nefarious purposes, which may be of interest to abroader policy audience. Cryptocurrency: Implications for Special Operations Forces includesthe following: (1) a detailed taxonomy and examples of nefarious activities usingcryptocurrencies, such as funding terrorist activity, money laundering, cybercrimes, andregulatory crimes; (2) a discussion of state-actor engagement in the cryptocurrency arena thatexplores Iranian, North Korean, Russian, and Venezuelan activity in skirting sanctions, miningcryptocurrencies, participating in exchange hacking and ransomware, and usingcryptocurrencies to fund information operations; (3) analysis attempting to anticipate the midterm future of the cryptocurrency ecosystem; and (4) the tactical and strategic challenges andopportunities of cryptocurrencies for SOF.S. John Spey, Leveraging Blockchain to Secure Logistics Information, CNA, 2018, DOP-2018-U-018289Final.3CNA Research Memorandum 2
What Are Cryptocurrencies?A cryptocurrency is (1) a strictly digital currency (i.e., not a digital exchange of conventionalcurrencies, such as US dollars), (2) typically decentralized, and (3) secured with cryptographicmethods. Ideally a cryptocurrency should function as a conventional currency (facilitating theexchange of goods and services), but it should do so in a public, transparent, and secure way. 4“Virtual currencies” and “virtual assets” are other terms to describe cryptocurrencies.Figure 1.Conventional currenciesWe use the phrase conventional currencies to refer to fiatcurrencies, which are currencies backed by the governments thatissue them. Importantly, this type of currency is not tied to a physicalgood. The linen of a US dollar itself has no intrinsi
Using crypto currencies also has relative benefits for those who engag e in illicit activity. In our companion paper, we explore cryptocurrency issues for SOF. hough written with a SOF Alt audience in mind, that report may b
Latin Primer 1: Teacher's Edition Latin Primer 1: Flashcard Set Latin Primer 1: Audio Guide CD Latin Primer: Book 2, Martha Wilson (coming soon) Latin Primer 2: Student Edition Latin Primer 2: Teacher's Edition Latin Primer 2: Flashcard Set Latin Primer 2: Audio Guide CD Latin Primer: Book 3, Martha Wilson (coming soon) Latin Primer 3 .
Bruksanvisning för bilstereo . Bruksanvisning for bilstereo . Instrukcja obsługi samochodowego odtwarzacza stereo . Operating Instructions for Car Stereo . 610-104 . SV . Bruksanvisning i original
10 tips och tricks för att lyckas med ert sap-projekt 20 SAPSANYTT 2/2015 De flesta projektledare känner säkert till Cobb’s paradox. Martin Cobb verkade som CIO för sekretariatet för Treasury Board of Canada 1995 då han ställde frågan
service i Norge och Finland drivs inom ramen för ett enskilt företag (NRK. 1 och Yleisradio), fin ns det i Sverige tre: Ett för tv (Sveriges Television , SVT ), ett för radio (Sveriges Radio , SR ) och ett för utbildnings program (Sveriges Utbildningsradio, UR, vilket till följd av sin begränsade storlek inte återfinns bland de 25 största
Hotell För hotell anges de tre klasserna A/B, C och D. Det betyder att den "normala" standarden C är acceptabel men att motiven för en högre standard är starka. Ljudklass C motsvarar de tidigare normkraven för hotell, ljudklass A/B motsvarar kraven för moderna hotell med hög standard och ljudklass D kan användas vid
when they sell the same cryptocurrency into fiat currency later on. Taxation of Cryptocurrency Block Rewards: Comparative Summary . The Law Library of Congress 3 . The income tax treatment of mining is
Understanding Cryptocurrency (updated May 2018) Ari Paul. CIO, Managing Partner. BlockTower Capital. Cryptocurrency is at the intersection of game theory, cryptography, computer science, economics, venture capital, and public markets. Don’t be scared. These
Apr 09, 2020 · of blockchain technology, cryptocurrency systems protect their public ledgers of accounts against manipulation, so that users can only send cryptocurrency to which they have access, thus allowing users to make val
This paper provides a concise yet comprehensive analysis of the cryptocurrency industry using the PESTLE model with a focus on Bitcoin and its investment. 1.6 Research Methods This paper is based on a descriptive study focuses on secondary data, the majority of information comes from journal articles, news, opinions from cryptocurrency .
och krav. Maskinerna skriver ut upp till fyra tum breda etiketter med direkt termoteknik och termotransferteknik och är lämpliga för en lång rad användningsområden på vertikala marknader. TD-seriens professionella etikettskrivare för . skrivbordet. Brothers nya avancerade 4-tums etikettskrivare för skrivbordet är effektiva och enkla att
Den kanadensiska språkvetaren Jim Cummins har visat i sin forskning från år 1979 att det kan ta 1 till 3 år för att lära sig ett vardagsspråk och mellan 5 till 7 år för att behärska ett akademiskt språk.4 Han införde två begrepp för att beskriva elevernas språkliga kompetens: BI
**Godkänd av MAN för upp till 120 000 km och Mercedes Benz, Volvo och Renault för upp till 100 000 km i enlighet med deras specifikationer. Faktiskt oljebyte beror på motortyp, körförhållanden, servicehistorik, OBD och bränslekvalitet. Se alltid tillverkarens instruktionsbok. Art.Nr. 159CAC Art.Nr. 159CAA Art.Nr. 159CAB Art.Nr. 217B1B
CARC MIL-C-46168 (9) Type IV topcoat CARC coatings. Two sets (M and P) labeled DTM were coated just with the epoxy primer and epoxy primer plus topcoat. Table 2. Wash primer coating systems. Substrate Pretreatment Primer Topcoat Cold rolled steel (CRS)1080 DOD-P-15328D or one of three vendors MIL-P-53030A e
10 ESP Primer System Instruction Guide p/n: 029-0810-01-0 Holding the primer ON for two (2) or three (3) seconds after a prime from draft will clean out residue in the primer. DO NOT run the primer over forty-five (45) seconds. If prime is not achieved within 45 seconds, stop
package PRIMER (Plymouth Routines In Multivariate Ecological Research), obtainable from PRIMER-e, (see www.primer-e.com). Its scope is the analysis of data arising in community ecology and environmental science which is multivariate in character (m
A Primer on Modern Monetary Theory / 3 financial capital is never a budgetary constraint on government spending has become a central policy tenet of MMT as it applies to countries such as Canada and the United States. The purpose of this primer is to elaborate upon and assess this cen-tral policy tenet. The primer proceeds as follows.
2000 Deponiskatt 2009 Certifiering av kompost inom Europa . methods supporting these treatment methods. Table 1. Policy instruments that are presented in the report . 2008 Green book: Management of bio waste (EU) 2010 Strategy for the use of biogas
include initial coin offerings or security token offerings (collectively, “ICOs”) to fund the issuer’s or promoter’s own business or project. Instead, ICOs are regulated under a separate regime, on which see below. Blockchain and cryptocurrency regulation 2019, first edition 3
Bitcoin and cryptocurrency technologies: a comprehensive introduction Princeton University Press, 2016. [2.4] Narayanan, Arvind, et al., How Bitcoin Achieves Decentralization, Chapter 2 in Bitcoin and cryptocurrency technologies: a comprehensive introduction, ibid. Week 3 Jan 22,34 Bitcoin and its variants [3.1] Nakamoto, Satoshi.
Reading Comprehension Study Guide and Practice Test 2015 Page 6 Part C: Reading Skill: Making Inferences Read the following passage and answer the questions that follow it. Of all the farm animals a person might own, the goat is the best personal pet. For one thing, you can keep it for a longer time than other farm animals. Even after a doe is .