Author(s): Richard Buchanan Source: Design Issues, Vol. 8 .

1y ago
23 Views
1 Downloads
455.17 KB
18 Pages
Last View : 8d ago
Last Download : 2m ago
Upload by : Maxine Vice
Transcription

Wicked Problems in Design ThinkingAuthor(s): Richard BuchananSource: Design Issues, Vol. 8, No. 2, (Spring, 1992), pp. 5-21Published by: The MIT PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1511637Accessed: 11/04/2008 09:41Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available rms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unlessyou have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and youmay use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained herCode mitpress.Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printedpage of such transmission.JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We enable thescholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform thatpromotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.http://www.jstor.org

.Richard Buchananin DesignThinkingWickedProblemsThisessayis basedon a paperpresentedat"Colloque Recherchessur le irst Frenchuniversitysymposiumondesign researchheld October 1990 rance.IntroductionDespite effortsto discoverthe foundationsof designthinkinginthe fine arts,the naturalsciences,or most recently,the socialsciences,designeludesreductionandremainsa surprisinglyflexibleactivity. No single definition of design, or branchesof professionalizedpracticesuchas industrialor graphicdesign,adequatelycoversthe diversityof ideasandmethodsgatheredtogetherunderthe label. Indeed,the varietyof researchreportedin conferencepapers,journalarticles,andbooks suggeststhatdesigncontinuesto expandin its meaningsand connections,revealingunexpecteddimensionsin practiceas well as understanding.This follows thetrendof designthinkingin the twentiethcentury,for we haveseento afielddesigngrowfroma tradeactivityto a segmentedprofessionfor technicalresearchandto what now shouldbe recognizedas anew liberalart of technologicalculture.It may seem unusualto talk about designas a liberalart,particularlywhen many people are accustomedto identifying theliberalartswith the traditional"artsand sciences"that are institutionalizedin colleges and universities.But the liberalarts areundergoinga revolutionarytransformationin twentieth-centuryculture, and design is one of the areasin which this transformationis strikingly evident.To understandthe change that is now underway, it is importantto recognize that what are commonly regarded as the liberal artstoday are not outside of history. They originatedin the Renaissanceand underwentprolonged development that culminatedin the nineteenth century as a vision of an encyclopedic educationof beaux arts,belles lettres,history, various naturalsciences and mathematics,philosophy, and the fledgling social sciences. This circle of learningwas divided into particular subject matters, each with a propermethod or set of methods suitable to its exploration. At their peakas liberal arts, these subject matters provided an integrated understandingof human experienceand the arrayof availableknowledge.By the end of the nineteenth century, however, existing subjectswere explored with progressively more refined methods, and newsubjects were added to accord with advances in knowledge. As aDesign Issues: Vol. VIII, Number 2 Spring 19925

1) From Richard McKeon, "TheTransformation of the Liberal Arts inthe Renaissance," Developments inthe Early Renaissance, ed. Bernard S.Levy (Albany: State University ofNew York Press, 1972), 168-69.2) Neo-positivism, pragmatism, and various forms of phenomenology havestrongly influenced design educationand practice in the twentieth century.If design theory has often tendedtoward neo-positivism, design practice has tended toward pragmatismand pluralism,with phenomenologistsin both areas. Such philosophical differences are illustrated in the split thatdeveloped between the theoreticalandstudio courses at the Hochschule furGestaltung (HfG) Ulm before its closing. The split between theory andpracticein design is an echo of the difference between the predominantlyneo-positivist philosophy of scienceand the exceptionally diverse philosophies of practicing scientists. Designhistory, theory, and criticism couldbenefit from closer attention to thepluralism of views that guide actualdesign practice.3) Walter Groupius was one of the first torecognize the beginnings of a new liberal art in design. In an essay writtenin 1937, he reflected on the foundingof the Bauhaus as an institutiongrounded on the idea of an architectonic art: "Thus the Bauhaus wasinaugurated in 1919 with the specificobject of realizing a modern architectonic art,which like human naturewasmeant to be all-embracingin its scope. Our guiding principle was thatdesign is neither an intellectual nor amaterial affair, but simply an integralpart of the stuff of life, necessary foreveryone in a civilized society." Scopeof Total Architecture (New York:Collier Books, 1970), 19-20. The term"architectonic,"in this case, transcendsthe derivative term "architecture" asit is commonly used in the modernworld. Throughout Western culture,the liberal arts have similarly beendescribed as "architectonic" becauseof their integrativecapacity. Groupiusappeared to understand that architecture, regardedas a liberalart in its ownright in the ancient world, was onlyone manifestation of the architectonic art of design in the twentiethcentury.4) John Dewey, The Quest for Certainty:A Study of the Relation of Knowledgeand Action (1929; rpt. New York:Capricorn Books, 1960), 290-91.6result,the circleof learningwas furtherdividedand subdivided,untilall thatremainedwas a patchworkquiltof specializations.Today, these subjectmattersretainan echo of theirold statusas liberalarts,buttheyflourishas specializedstudies,leadingto theperceptionof an evermorerichanddetailedarrayof factsandvalues.Althoughthesesubjectscontributeto theadvanceof knowledge,as they havebecomeprothey alsocontributeto its fragmentation,gressively narrow in scope, more numerous, and have lost"connectionwith eachotherandwith the commonproblemsandmattersof daily life from which they select aspects for precisemethodologicalanalysis."'The searchfor new integrativedisciplinesto complementthe artsandscienceshasbecomeone of thecentralthemesof intellectualandpracticallife in the twentiethcentury. Without integrative disciplines of understanding,communication,andaction,thereis littlehope of sensiblyextending knowledgebeyondthe libraryor laboratoryin orderto servethe purposeof enrichinghumanlife.The emergenceof designthinkingin the twentiethcenturyisimportantin this context.The significanceof seekinga scientificbasisfor designdoes not lie in the likelihoodof reducingdesigntoone or anotherof the sciences-anextensionof the neo-positivistprojectandstillpresentedin thesetermsby somedesigntheoristsRather,it lies in a concernto connectandintegrateusefulknowledge from the artsand sciencesalike,but in ways that are suitedto theproblemsandpurposesof thepresent.Designers,areexploring concreteintegrationsof knowledgethatwill combinetheorywith practicefor new productivepurposes,and this is the reasonwhy we turnto designthinkingfor insightinto the new liberalartsof technologicalcultureDesign and Intentional OperationsThe beginningof the study of designas a liberalartcan be tracedto the culturalupheavalthatoccurredin the earlypartof the twentieth century.The key featureof this upheavalwas describedbyJohnDewey in TheQuestforCertaintyas the perceptionof a newcenterof the universe.Theold centerof theuniversewasthemindknowingby,meansof anequipmentof nantecedentexternalmaterial equallycompletewithin itself. The new centerisindefiniteinteractionstakingplacewithin a courseofnaturewhichis notfixedandcomplete,butwhichis capable of directionto new anddifferentresultsthroughthemediationof intentionaloperations.WhatDewey describeshereis the root of the differencebetweenthe old andnew liberalarts,betweenspecializationin the factsof asubjectmatterandtheuseof new disciplinesof integrativethinking.

5) John Dewey, Experience and Nature(1929; rpt. New York: DoverPublications, Inc., 1958), 357.6) Dewey, Experience and Nature, 35758.International7) The neo-positivistEncyclopedia of Unified Science,which included Charles Morris'sFoundations of the Theory of Signs,also included Dewey's Theory ofValuation. However, Dewey's Logicwas ignored or ridiculed by neo-positivist logicians and grammarians.8) John Dewey, "By Nature and By Art,"Philosophy of Education (Problemsof Men) (1946; rpt. Totowa, NewJersey: Littlefield, Adams, 1958), 288.9) Dewey, "By Nature and By Art," 29192.Dewey observes,however,that the meaningand implicationsof the new directionarestill not fully understood.Nowadayswe havea messyconjunctionof notionsthatare consistentneitherwith one anothernor with thetenorof our actuallife. Knowledgeis still regardedbymostthinkersasdirectgraspof ultimatereality,althoughthepracticeof knowinghasbeenassimilatedto theprocedureof theusefularts;-involving,thatis to say,doingthat manipulatesand arrangesnaturalenergies.Againwhile science is said to lay hold of reality,yet "art"insteadof beingassigneda lowerrankis sfurther,Dewey exploresthe new relationshipbetweenscience,art,andpractice.He suggestsin Experienceand Nature that knowledgeis no longerachievedby directconformity of ideas with the fixed orders of nature;knowledge isachievedby a new kind of artdirectedtowardordersof change.Butif moderntendenciesarejustifiedin puttingartandcreationfirst, then the implicationsof this positionshouldbe avowedandcarriedthrough.It would thenbe seen that scienceis an art, that art is practice,andthatthe only distinctionworthdrawingis not betweenpracticeandtheory,but betweenthose modesof practice that are not intelligent, not inherently andimmediatelyenjoyable, and those which are full ofenjoyedmeanings.Althoughthe neo-positivistscourtedDewey for a time,it wasapparentthat his understandingof the developmentof scienceinthe twentiethcenturywas quite differentfrom theirunderstanding7.Insteadof treatingscienceas primaryand art as secondary,Dewey pointedtowardscienceas art.Theconsiderationthatcompletesthe groundfor assimilating science to art is the fact that assignment ofscientificstatusin oduced.Scienceis now the product of operationsdeliberatelyundertakenin conformitywith a planor projectthathasthepropertiesof a working hypothesis.WhatDeweymeansby "art"in thiscontextis crucialto understandculture.ingthenewroleof designandtechnologyin contemporaryAftera periodin crafts,scienceentereduponborrowinga periodof steadyandever-acceleratedgrowthby meansof deliberateinventionof such applianceson its ownaccount.Inorderto markthisdifferentialfeatureof theartwhichis science,I shallnow usetheword"technology.". Becauseof technologies,acircularbetweenrelationshiptheartsof productionandsciencehasbeenestablished.Design Issues: Vol. VIII, Number 2 Spring 19927

10) For Dewey, the artsof production,includethefinearts.He makesno sharpshadtinction betweenbeteen fineandusefuldistinctionarts.What Dewey defines as technology is not what is commonlyunderstoodin today'sphilosophyof technology.Insteadof meaning knowledgeof how to makeand use artifactsor the artifactsthemselves,technologyfor Dewey is anartof experimentalthinking. It is, in fact, intentionaloperationsthemselvescarriedout inthe sciences,the artsof production, or socialandpoliticalaction.We mistakenly identify technology with one particular type ofproduct-hardware-that may result from experimentalthinking, but overlookthe artthatlies behindandprovidesthe basisforcreatingother types of products.Fromthis perspective,it is easy to understandwhy designanddesign thinkingcontinueto expandtheir meaningsand connections in contemporaryculture.Thereis no areaof contemporarylife wheredesign-the plan,project,or workinghypothesiswhichconstitutesthe "intention"in intentionaloperations-is not a significantfactorin shapinghumanexperience.Design evenextendsinto the coreof traditionalscientificactivities,whereit is employedto cultivate the subject mattersthat are the focus of scientificcuriosity.But perceivingthe existenceof such an art only opensthe door to furtherinquiry, to explainwhat that art is, how itoperates,andwhy it succeedsor failsin particularsituations.Thechallengeis to gaina deeperunderstandingof designthinkingsothat more cooperation and mutual benefit is possible betweenthosewho applydesignthinkingto ill helpto makethepracticalexplorationof design,particularlyin the artsof production,more intelligentand meaningful.However,a persistentproblemin this regardis thatdiscussionsbetweendesignersand membersof the scientificcommunitytendto leavelittle room for reflectionon the broadernatureof designandits relationto the artsand hegeneralpublicthatultimatelying,marketinguses the resultsof designthinking.Insteadof yieldingproductiveintegrations,the resultis oftenconfusionanda breakdownof communication,with a lack of intelligentpracticeto carryinnovativeideasinto objective,concreteembodiment.In turn,thisundermineseffortsto reacha clearerunderstandingof designitself,sometimesdrivingdesignersbackinto a defenseof theirwork in the contextof ionto cipants,amongis littlehope of understandingthe foundationsandvalueof designthinkingin an increasinglycomplextechnologicalculture.The Doctrine of PlacementsBy "liberalart"I meana disciplineof thinkingthatmaybe sharedto some degreeby all men andwomen in their daily lives and is,in turn,masteredby a few peoplewho practicethe eit to new areasof inno8

11)HerbertA. Simon,TheSciencesof houghSimon'sTheSciencesof theArtificialis citedrepeatedlyin designliteraturebecauseof its definitionofdesign,it is oftenreadwithlittleattention given to the full argument.Acarefulanalysisfromthe standpointof industrialdesignwould be a useSuchfulcontributionto theliterature.a readingwould revealthe positivistandhelpfeaturesof Simon'sapproachto explainwhy many designersaresomewhat disenchantedwith thebook. Nonetheless, it remains anexceptionallyusefulwork.13) See ernicanRevolution,"Revue des sciencesettechniquesde la conception (TheJournal of Design Sciences shculture"is usedby literarycriticGeorgeSteinerandis a themein a forthcomingbook byof theText.IvanIllich,IntheVineyard15)Thedesignof materialobjectsincludes,of course,new workin materialsscience,wherea highlyfocusedformofdesignthinkingis evident.vativeapplication.Perhapsthisis whatHerbertSimonmeantin TheSciencesof the Artificial,one of the majorworks of designtheoryin the twentieth century,when he wrote: "the proper study ofmankindis the scienceof design,not only as theprofessionalcomponent of a technicaleducationbut as a core disciplinefor everyliberallyeducatedman.""One mayreasonablydisagreewithaspectsof Simon'spositivistand empiricistview of design as a science(asone ndtheofobservationimportanceof intentionaloperationsDewey'sin modernculture),'but thereis little reasonto disagreewith theidea that all men and women may benefitfrom an early understandingof the disciplinesof designin the contemporaryworld.The beginningof such an understandinghas alreadyturnedthestudy of the traditionalarts and sciencestoward a new engagement with the problemsof everydayexperience,evident in thedevelopmentof diversenew productswhich incorporateknowledgefrom manyfieldsof specializedinquiry.To gain some idea of how extensivelydesign n whichdesignis exploredthroughoutthe worldby professionaldesignersandby manyotherswho maynot regardthemselvesas designers.The firstof theseThisareasis the design of symbolicand visual communications.includesthe traditionalwork of graphicdesign,such as typography andadvertising,book t has expandedinto communicationthroughphotography, film, television, and computer display. The area ofcommunicationsdesign is rapidlyevolving into a broad explorationof the problemsof a new synthesisof words and imagesthat istransformingthe "bookishculture"of the past.lThe secondareais the designof materialobjects.This includesof everydaytraditionalconcernfor the formandvisualappearanceproducts-clothing, domesticobjects,tools, instruments,machinery, and vehicles-but has expandedinto a more thoroughanddiverseinterpretationof the physical,psychological,social, elationshipsis rapidlyevolving into an explorationof the problemsof conmustcarrya deeper,structionin whichformandvisualappearancemore integrativeargumentthat unitesaspectsof art,engineeringandnaturalscience,andthe humansciences.5The thirdareais the designof activitiesand organizedservices,which includesthe traditionalmanagementconcernfor ,instrumentalities,in efficientsequencesand schedulesto reachspecifiedobjectives.However, this areahas expandedinto a concernfor logicaldecision makingandstrategicplanningandis rapidlyevolvinginto anexplorationof how betterdesignthinkingcancontributeto achievinganorganicflow of experiencein concretesituations,makingsuchDesign Issues: Vol. VIII, Number 2 Spring 19929

experiences more intelligent, meaningful, and satisfying. The central theme of this area is connections and consequences. Designersare exploring a progressively wider range of connections in everyday experience and how different types of connections affect theandSomeofthesocialstructure of action.616)psychologicalof thisareaareillustratedindimensionsThe fourth area is the design of complex systems or environworksas diverseas GeorgeA. Miller,mentsandKarlH.Galanter,Pribram,Eugenefor living, working, playing, and learning. This includes theofBehaviorPlansandtheStructure(New traditionalconcerns ofsystems engineering,architecture,and urbanYork:Holt, Rinehartand Winston,PlansandSituated planning or the functional analysis of the parts of complex wholes1960);LucySuchman,Actions:The Problem of Human- and theirsubsequent integration in hierarchies. But this area hasMachineCommunication(Cambridge:alsoexpanded and reflects more consciousness of the central alyCsikszentmihalyi,thought, or value that expresses the unity of any balancedand funcPsychology of OptimalExperiencetioning whole. This areais more and more concernedwith exploring(NewYork:Harper& Row,1990).the role of design in sustaining, developing, and integrating humanbeings into broader ecological and cultural environments, shapingthese environments when desirable and possible or adapting to17)Oneof theearlyworksof systemsengi- them when ecting on this list of the areasof design thinking, it is temptis ArthurD. Hall,A Methodologyforto identify and limit

The emergence of design thinking in the twentieth century is important in this context. The significance of seeking a scientific basis for design does not lie in the likelihood of reducing design to one or another of the sciences-an extension of the neo-positivist project and still presented in these terms by some design theorists

Related Documents:

Death Certificate Index - Buchanan County (1935-1939) 9/13/2015 Page 1 Name Birth Date Birth Place Death Date County Mother's Maiden Name Number Box Abel, Mary M. 08 Oct. 1866 Iowa 17 Aug. 1938 Buchanan Unknown J10-0211 D2856 Abplanalp, Fritz c.1880 Germany 09 Jan. 1939 Buchanan Unknown 010-0019 D2889

the Source 1 power source until the Source 2 power source does appear. Conversely, if connected to the Source 2 power source and the Source 2 power source fails while the Source 1 power source is still unavailable, the ATS remains connected to the Source 2 power source. ATSs automatically perform the transfer function and include three basic .

Richard Buchanan at the San Diego County jail. OVERT ACT NO.18 On June 4, 2006, December 25, 2006, J anuary 28, 2007, March 18, 2007, and June 24, 2007, Eden Macias Portugal deposited money into Richard Buchanan’s account at the San Diego County jail. OVERT ACT NO. 19 On June 4 and 26, 2006, September 2, 2006, November 12 and 29 2006,

Intrusion Detection Systems Introduction Threats Types Host or Network? Agent-based Snort A simple rule A few intrusions User profiling Honeypots IPS Conclusions Eve (Intruder) Defence Intrusion Detection Defence. Author: Bill Buchanan Author:Prof Bill Buchanan Intrusion Detection Systems

Independent Personal Pronouns Personal Pronouns in Hebrew Person, Gender, Number Singular Person, Gender, Number Plural 3ms (he, it) א ִוה 3mp (they) Sֵה ,הַָּ֫ ֵה 3fs (she, it) א O ה 3fp (they) Uֵה , הַָּ֫ ֵה 2ms (you) הָּ תַא2mp (you all) Sֶּ תַא 2fs (you) ְ תַא 2fp (you

Software Source Code: Perl Source (By content) Software Source Code: Perl Source (By file extension) Software Source Code: Python (Default) Software Source Code: Python (Wide) Software Source Code: x86 Assembly Source Code SPICE Source Code Policy for detection of integrated circuits design source code in SPICE

WT I0 Wood Turning with Richard Raffan Richard Raffan WT 11Turning Projects Richard Raffan WT 12 Turning Projects Richard Raffan WT l3 Turned Bowl Design Richard Raffan WT 14 Turned Boxes Richard Raffan WT 15 The Practice of Wood Turning Mike

individuality or conformity. Synthesize at least three of the sources for support. You may refer to the sources by their titles (Source A, Source B, etc.) or by the descriptions in the parentheses. Source A (Gatto) Source B (Bell schedule) Source C (Book cover) Source D (Postman) Source E (Holt) Source F (Photo) Source G (Expectations)

Lisa Gonzales 3/2020 Surgical APP Author Dyer Heintz 3/2020 GI MD Author R. Boeck 01/2014 ED MD Author M. Iyer 01/2014 DCMC CMO Author E. Davis 01/2014 Inpatient Author J. Nowlin 01/2014 ENT MD Author J. Sanchez 01/2014 Surgeon Author D. Danaher 01/2014 EBOC PM Author

core elements: author, title, publisher, date, location etc 19 works cited: template method 25 author types 25 one author & two authors 25 three or more authors 25 two or more works by the same author 25 author and editor or translator 26 organization or government as author 26 unknown author 26 source types periodicals - online & print 27

Richard Clayderman - The Music Of Love (Piano Solo) Richard Clayderman. THE PIANO SOLOS OF. RICHARD CLAYDERMAN. 2 Ballade Pour Adeline . 30 Love Is A Many-Splendored Thing. 33

with Ms. Wallach or Mr. Tucker, please contact Bryan Buchanan, press officer for Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch, at (202) 454-5108 or at bbuchanan@citizen.org. REPORTERS’ MEMO March 30, 2011 Contact : Bryan Buchanan (202) 454-5108 Here’s an Impediment to Job Creation That Ways and Means Hearing

Technical Report Documentation Page . 1. Report No. 2. Government Accession No. 3. Recipient’s Catalog No. InTrans Project 12-427 . 4. Title and Subtitle 5. Report Date . Evaluation of the Buchanan County IBRD Bridge on Victor Avenue over Prairie Creek September 2017 . 6. Performing Orga

a special thank you to Buchanan Auto Stores for partnering with the school system to support the Carroll County Teacher of the Year Program for the sixth consecutive year. As part of the partnership, Buchanan Auto Stores provides the Carroll County Teacher of the Year with the use of a new K

us once you see fit to resume discussion. ommunication promptly resumed— not about the censure directly, however, but rather about the case of Dr. Teresa K. Buchanan described in this report. Professor Buchanan earned bachelor [

Later, after Bishop Dotcy Isom became the presiding prelate over the Third Episcopal District, Rev. Buchanan was appointed the pastor of Carter Metropolitan C.M.E. in During the years Pastor Buchanan served in Detroit, he became widely known and sought after to conduct workshops for his prolific teach

Adam, Liz Hume Liz Hume Adam Crozet Adams, Carol Carol Adams Richmond Agee, Marcie Marcie Agee Henrico . Herbert Rev. Herbert Brynildsen Hampton Buchanan, Martha Ms. Martha Buchanan Radford . Forrester, Douglas Rev. Douglas Forrester Richmond Foster, Martha Martha Foster N.

Robert W. Buchanan, M.D. 2 . Institutional Service: 1993 - Present Executive Committee, Maryland Psychiatric Research Center, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, Maryland . 1998 - 2008 Intervention Research Center/Advanced Centers for Interventions and Services

Feb 12, 2013 · Bryant, John Clifton TX 11/19/2013 M Buchanan, John S. Peaster TX 5/18/2013 M Buehrer, Wayne Poteet TX 6/22/2013 M Bullard, Tommy, DVM Weatherford TX 4/18/2013 M Burch, Lonnie Buchanan Dam TX 12/4/2012 M Burleigh, Deborah Rose Muldoon TX 2/4/2013 J2 Burleson, Mike Rosebud TX 2/22/2222 L

American Chemet John and Nina Baucus Dianne L. Beaman Sara Berg Jock and Tere Bovington Charles Bozdog Jan Brown Erik and Shannon Brown Carol Bruderer Shawn and Lynn* Bubb Norma and Gary Buchanan Todd and Brooke Buchanan Pam Bucy Steve and Lisa Bullock Burke Family Clay* and Alesa Burkett Art and Amie Butler Allen and Kathy Chambers Carolyn Clemens