The 9 Pillars Of Great School Leadership

2y ago
68 Views
2 Downloads
1.82 MB
13 Pages
Last View : 1d ago
Last Download : 3m ago
Upload by : Alexia Money
Transcription

PROFESSOR DAVID WOODS, CBEDavid Woods has been a teacher and senior leader in schools, a teachertrainer in higher education and a local authority adviser in two LAs. He wasthe Chief Education Adviser for the City of Birmingham before joining theDepartment for Education in England as a Senior Education Adviser workingclosely with Ministers to develop educational policy and subsequentlybecoming Head of the Department’s Advisory Service. He joined the LondonChallenge programme from the beginning as the Lead Adviser and thenThe Nine Pillars of GreatSchool Leadershipbecame the Chief Adviser for London Schools and the London Challenge. Hehas the unique distinction of having being the Chief Education Adviser forEngland’s two biggest cities, Birmingham and London. He has written andspoken extensively on educational leadership, on school improvement, andDavid Woodsrelated education matters. Currently he is an Education Consultant workingwith schools, local authorities, Multi-Academy Trusts and Teaching Schools, aswell as being a Visiting Professor at the Institute of Education, UniversityCollege, London. He is also the Chair of the Birmingham School ImprovementOctober 2020Advisory Committee as well as being a member of the National EducationCommission for Wales.The Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

The Nine Pillars ofGreat School Leadership‘A definition of leadership is to createthe conditions for people to thrive,individually and collectively andachieve significant goals’.David Pendleton and Adrian FurnhamLeadership: All you Need to KnowPillar 1 – Moral, Ethical and Compassionate LeadershipPillar 2 – Inspirational and Transformational LeadershipPillar 3 – Strategic and Operational LeadershipPillar 4 – Learning Focused LeadershipPillar 5 – Student Centred LeadershipPillar 6 – Distributed and Invitational LeadershipPillar 7 – Leadership Accountability for Performance‘Leadership is lifting a person’s vision to highspirits, the raising of a person’s performanceto a higher standard, the building of apersonality beyond its normal limitations’.Peter DruckerManaging in a Time of Great Change‘Leadership can be defined as the will tocontrol events, the understanding to chart acourse, and the power to get a job doneco-operatively using the skills and abilities ofpeople’.Donald KrausePillar 8 – Leadership for Well-BeingPillar 9 – System Leadership‘A leader is an individual who significantlyaffects the thoughts, feelings andbehaviours of a significant number ofindividuals’.Howard GardnerLeading Minds: An Anatomy of LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

INTRODUCTIONGreat leadership matters – from the frontline of the school to the Headteacherbetween transactional and transformational leadership, the critical importanceit is the most important advantage any school can have. That is why there isof ethical leadership and vision and values, the personal behaviour andso much attention paid to it with a huge growth in the published literature andattitudes of leaders, leadership styles, the distribution of leadership withinit is a rich area of on-going research. This pamphlet seeks to identify from theschools and the focus on the core business of teaching and learning. In recentliterature and action research the characteristics of great school leadership. It isyears the concept of system leadership has assumed greater importance. Therepart of a series which first identified the Nine Pillars of Great Schools (2016 andis currently an on-going debate concerning the need for a greater focus on2018) based on the literature and nine volumes of case studies from London’s‘domain specific knowledge’ rather than on generic leadership skills andoutstanding schools published between 2010 and 2019. Many of these casebehaviours particularly in terms of leadership development. A glance at thestudies were based on aspects of great school leadership. It is recognised thattitles of school leadership books and articles over recent years reveals some ofthe term ‘great’ is rather subjective and that OfSTED, for example, only goesthese complexities in examining the qualities and dimensions of great schoolas far as ‘outstanding ‘ in their description of the best schools and otherleadership. They range across ‘Authentic Leadership’, ‘Passionate Leadership’,commentators refer to ‘high performing’ or ‘successful’ leaders and schools.‘Leading with Substance’, ‘Learning-Centred Leadership’, ‘Leadership andAfter much discussion and debate with a range of Headteachers a definitionSustainability, ‘Distributed Leadership’, ‘Leading in a Culture of Change’,of greatness emerged as ‘sustained excellence’, ‘exceptionality’ and ‘superior‘Focused Leadership’, ‘Leverage Leadership’, ‘Servant Leadership’, ‘Leadershipquality and character’. The importance of context also needs to be recognised.for Well-Being’ and ‘Nuanced Leadership‘. There seems to be a growingGreat schools vary in age-range and phase, size, poverty and privilege, type andconsensus that the key aspects of contemporary school leadership are visiontradition, and rural and urban locations. In particular their social contexts andand values, creating alignment and motivation, embracing change, thepupil intakes differ as well as the quality of their buildings and resources.empowerment of others and building commitment.However, despite these considerable differences it can be argued from theliterature, research, and practical examples that great schools do share anumber of key dimensions and characteristics, particularly excellence in leadership throughout the school, which are described in these nine pillars.The Framework and characteristics that are described here in the Nine Pillarsof Great School Leadership seeks to provide a tool for school leaders to reflecton their practice and performance. It may be that leaders would want to refinethese pillars and characteristics to better reflect their own context andOver the last 20 years various themes and dimensions have emerged toexperience but hopefully this publication has captured the essential dimensionsdescribe the best school leadership which have also generated some rigorousof great school leadership, to stimulate a rich debate not only amongstdebate between researchers and practitioners. For example, the balanceHeadteachers and Senior Leaders but also middle leaders and all staff.The Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

1Moral, Ethical andCompassionate Leadership Leaders recognise that the route to great‘Extending the vision of what is possible involvesbeing historian and futurologist. Any leaderwishing to do this is deeply aware of this doublerequirement: the present dominates so much ofschool life. And if sometimes that present seemsoverwhelming, the energy levels dip. So tellingstories which remind people of past success andkeeps predecessors and the school happy, areboth things wise leaders do. But they are alsoforecasters of the weather and describers offuture possibilities : they confidentially describe apath from the present to the future. They aregood listeners and readers. They write ’future’pieces for their community. They ask ’why not’aloud and ’why’ silently in their heads’.Sir Tim BrighouseHow Successful Headteachers Survive and Thrive There is a core belief amongst leaders thatschooling lies in moral purpose: thedetermination, brought to reality, to ensure thatall members of the school community behave ina way that is mindful of each other. A compellingand inclusive moral purpose drives the schoolforward based on equity, social justice andunshakeable principles to be shared and actedupon by everyone. There is a deeply embedded set of strongly heldvalues. Leaders articulate and reinforce clearvalues through their daily interactions with staffand pupils and work with governors. They ensurethat basic assumptions and beliefs are sharedand that all children and young people receivethe best possible education whatever therealities of race, poverty and other socialbarriers. The school’s culture and ethos result from theapplication of its vision and values and manifestthemselves in customs, symbols, stories andlanguage. They are successfully expressedthrough ways that leaders and members of theschool community relate to each other and worktogether. Leaders recognise the schools cannot becompassion is the key organising principle ineducation, promoting the highest, collectivevalues with fidelity to every person’s culturalvalue. Leaders strive to develop acompassionate school community andcurriculum that ensures everybody’s wellbeing. They demonstrate respect, generosity ofspirit and understanding. Leaders are considerate and dutiful,demonstrating humility and self-control. Theysee themselves working in the service of othersacting with courage in the best interest of theschool community to deliver a broad, balanced,creative, and inclusive education, and to develop a set of ethical understandings. Leaders are selfless leading with empathy andhumanity acting only in the interests of childrenand young people so that they may lead useful,happy, and fulfilling lives. They act withintegrity and establish a climate of opennesstaking decisions in a transparent manner. Leaders are fully aware of the broader purposeof education and the importance of consideringwhat they hope will become of their childrenconsidered great without due attention beingpaid to spiritual, moral, social and culturaleducation and deeper thinking about thepurpose and development of values and skillsthat are at the heart of these aspects ofeducation.and young people when they finally leaveschool. They strive to create a moral and ethicalcommunity in the hope that their students liveup to altruistic ideas and values and care foreach other and the planet.‘Our schools are the social embryos of humanity – those institutions that are establishedto promote our highest collective values. They should be the embodiment of norms ofreciprocity, active trust and democratic deliberation .They need leadership that lifts usup and turns us around together in pursuit of a common cause that expresses andadvances our humanity’.’Andy Hargreaves and Dennis Shirley - The Fourth WayThe Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

2Inspirational andTransformational Leadership Leaders recognise that incremental change isn’tenough and aim for transformation withreference back to the current and known worldand to future possibilities. They recognise thatthe time to explore transformational change iswhen things are apparently going well. They arefiercely committed to creating a better futurewith the people they lead.‘The longest lever we have at our disposal isleadership: Leadership at all levels, leaders wholeave behind a legacy of leaders that can go evenfurther, leaders who step out to make widercontributions and a pipeline of leadersdeveloping their dispositions and skills it isimpossible to get a system perspective if we onlystay at home. We need cross–connectedleadership experiences in order to transform thesystem so that progressive cultures flourish’.Michael FullanLeadership and Sustainability - SystemThinkers in Action The school’s leadership is visionary, inspiringand values based. Leaders extend the vision ofwhat is possible and confidently describe a pathfrom the present to the future – redirectingapproaches, anticipating developments andinspiring changes through being bold, positiveand ambitious. The vision of the school is clear, understoodand shared by all, underpinned by the school’svalues, philosophy, and ethos. All members ofthe school community promote the vision of theschool and the collective vision permeates thewhole institution. Transformational and inspirational leadership ismore than meeting existing needs or demandsfrom followers. It focuses on the people involvedand seeks to transform attitudes and beliefs,unleashing energy and motivation. It aims todevelop mature, stimulating relationships thatwill secure the maximum commitment from theschool community. Leaders create and manage culture. Inparticular, there is a culture of highexpectations. Leaders lead with enthusiasm andencouragement, empowering people and givingthem the opportunity to do their best. Positivelanguage increases aspirational thinking.Everyone feels fulfilled in what they do andcontributes to the fulfilment of others. Leaders lead by example – with trust, integrity,resilience, clarity and a heart-felt set ofpersonal values which they demonstrate toothers. They draw on their own scholarshipexperience and skills to influence those aroundthem. They are highly visible and reinforced theschool’s vision every day, inspiring staff andpupils to excellence. Leaders find time and space for creativity andinnovation throughout the school. They arerestless in their desire both to improve andtransform their school, looking outwards whereappropriate to seize ideas which they cancustomise to their own content. The vision and aspirations of the school and itsleaders are always optimistic and based upon agrowth mindset philosophy. There is no ceilingon hope and no cap on ambition. Leaderscreate excitement, idealism and confidence.‘The very essence of leadership is that you have to have a vision. It’s got to be a visionthat you articulate clearly and forcefully on every occasion. You can’t blow an uncertaintrumpet’.Theodore HesburghThe Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

3Strategic and OperationalLeadership Leaders have one foot in the present and Leaders pay great attention to the develop-another in the future. They make clear strategicchoices and once these get made they are adeptat managing the necessary changes throughpassionate communication, clarity of goals,maintaining the focus and careful evaluation.They are adaptive leaders with the ability tomobilise action and to promote collaboration. Strategic leadership hinges on effectivelyment of teams and team-working in order todeliver the overall strategy of the school and toprovide clarity and consistency of practice onthe front line. They establish a climate ofopenness and take decisions in a transparentmanner. There is a continuous process of reflection andcapturing and directing attention. The school’sstrategy represents the desired pattern oforganisational attention which everybody keepsin mind in their own way. Leaders know thatdirecting attention to where it needs to go is aprimal test of their leadership.feedback amongst leaders at all levels thatbecomes implicit and in which all talk abouttheir work and learning. The school as anorganisation learns its way forwardcontinuously striving to improve its processesand systems within the overall strategy forimprovement. Well-focused leaders can balance an inner focus The quest for excellence becomes a habit foron the direction, culture and performance of theschool with an outer focus on the large realitiesthat shape the changing learning environment,with time to reflect and see the bigger picture.They are good listeners and readers, sensingtrends and emerging realities, ready to seize theopportunities for change. There is excellent operational and organisationalleadership, enabling systems to work well.Leaders recognise the crucial importance offocusing on the right things and doing them right.They are highly effective planners, resourcers andorganisers, paying attention to detail and gettingresults. They successfully align internal structuresto overarching values and goals.leaders and their purposeful practice. There isan embedded culture of thinking and doing,building momentum and maintaining highimpact over a sustained period of time. Leaders recognise that there can be littleprogress without unity of purpose and action,harnessing the individual and group capacity tomake improvements. People are energised towelcome change in a climate of trust. Theyunderstand what needs to be done and theirrole in helping to improve practice and takepride in the process.‘Outstanding leaders think and actsystematically. In contrast to good leaders, theoutstanding leaders see wholes move fluidly fromelement to element and join up their thinkingand the organization’s activity. Central to all thisis a keen sense of purpose and theirunderstanding of how different aspects oforganizations internally connect. Purpose drivesperformance and the outstanding leaders bothunderstand this and refuse to allow anything tostand in the way’.John Pendleton and Adrian FurnhamLeadership: All you Need to Know‘The focus for leadership in actively improving schools is the creation and expansion ofimprovement capacity. Such capacity change—culture, structure and knowledge—supports continuous organisational and professional renewal’.David Hopkins - School Improvement for RealThe Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

4Learning FocusedLeadership A relentless focus on high quality learning andteaching is at the heart of the school’sendeavours – ‘learning without limits’ and‘success for all’ are guiding principles for schoolleaders. Leaders demand ambitious standards forall pupils overcoming disadvantage andadvancing equality. Leaders regularly and openly model their learningand articulate their own learning challenges andgoals but also shape the conditions for all tosuccessfully learn on a continuous basis. Leadership has a direct impact on the quality of teaching and learning. The school is a knowledge – creating institutionwhere leaders embed a collaborative learningculture. Professional knowledge is continuallyexamined and reviewed and new knowledgedeveloped and shared. Leaders have acommitment to building professional capital bylooking to research evidence, seeking outexamples of brilliant practice in their own andother schools and disseminating it effectively. Leaders are enquiry-minded, geared toinnovation and action research. They are inconstant pursuit of ideas, evidence andknowledge, with a passion for curiosity. Leadersare highly reflective about their work and adeptat mobilising the school’s intellectual andcreative capital to produce excellent educationaloutcomes. Leaders enable the school to be at theforefront of successful and innovativecurriculum design providing the entirety ofeducational experience so that pupils can livefulfilling lives. Leaders ensure the acquisition ofknowledge and understanding, the development of learning skills and the fostering ofpositive character traits. Learning and teaching are personalisedthroughout the curriculum through tailoredprogrammes for a wide range of pupils withdifferent needs, so that all are able toparticipate, progress and achieve. Leaders invest in a variety of learningtechnologies and resources which encourageand stimulate independent learning and areused highly effectively and imaginatively bystaff and pupils. Leaders help the school function as aprofessional learning community wherecommunities of practice are fostered anddeveloped. They are able to review and adaptexisting practices through regularconversations to develop exemplary pedagogyand to lead high quality professionaldevelopment.‘One of the key principles of leadership is that leaders must strive to be model learners.They must continue to read and engage in discussions about all manner of subjects aswell as the most recent theories of learning. As leaders they should question currentpractices and never feel that they have progressed beyond being a learner’.5Student Centred Leadership Leaders make sure that pupils are involved inleading, managing and planning their owneducational experience at all levels. Pupils areencouraged to carry out their own lines ofenquiry and participate in focus groupsinvestigating and reporting back on school issues. Leaders are heavily involved in ensuring thequality of teaching. They develop a shared theoryof effective teaching in particular contexts. Thisforms the basis of a coherent teachingprogrammes focused on the best learning andwellbeing for children and young people. Leaders develop the capacity of teachers to teachwhat pupils need to learn whilst beingopen-minded about what that is and how toachieve it. They have expert knowledge of thetypes of professional development that are morelikely to make an impact on the pupils of theparticipating teachers. Leaders ensure a safe, secure and well-ordered The student voice is strong throughout theschool. Leaders empower and encouragestudents to suggest improvements to theschool and ways to help them learn better andfoster their well-being. They participate fullythrough School Councils and StudentLeadership teams, surveys, feedback andevaluations. School leaders make sure thattheir voice counts. Pupils are recognised as citizens of the schoolin a real sense. They may, for example,contribute to school publications andcommunications, observe and evaluatelearning, be represented on working partiesand represent the school as ambassadors andguides. Leaders ensure a strong focus on pupil wellbeing and safeguarding. Peer counsellors,mediators and mentors are used to maintainand rebuild pupil relationships.environment for both pupils and staff whichincludes school and class routines that prioritiseexemplary behaviour and protect learning time. Leaders resource strategically and therebyextend teachers’ capacity. Crucially, time andteaching materials are allocated to maximisestudent-centred learning.‘’The more leaders focus their relationships, their work and their learning on the corebusiness of teaching and learning the greater their influence on student outcomes.’Vivianne Robinson - Student-Centred LeadershipT.J. Sergiovanni - Leadership: What’s in it for Schools?The Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

6Distributed and InvitationalLeadership Leaders practise invitational and distributedleadership in the belief that all have potential forgrowth and development and have differentleadership qualities as well as expert knowledge. The first role of leadership is that it is shared,‘For leaders to get results they need three kindsof focus. Inner focus attunes our intuitions,guiding values and better decisions. Other focuslets us navigate in the larger world. A leaderturned out of his internal world will berudderless; one blind to the world of others willbe clueless; those indifferent to the largersystems within which they operate will beblindsided. Leaders need the full range of inner,other and outer focus to excel - a weakness inany one of them can throw a leader off balance’.with the aim of building leadership capacity andownership in making significant decisions.Invitational school leaders invite everybody towear the mantle of leadership at different levelsand be part of achieving the vision and thejourney to success. Strategic development is inclusive throughinviting a range of leaders at different times toparticipate in achieving a common view of whatis required to sustain success. Invitational leaders welcome internal andexternal challenge stimulating professionaldialogue. They encourage the staff to take onmore responsibility and accountability for theirown decisions as part of the collectiveaccountability of the school. Leaders empower through delegating highlevels of authority. What has to be done isusually defined but how it is done is left tothose who have the responsibility which mightmean control over resources, methods anddecision making. The best leaders grow future leaders. There isa clear policy and programme to developleadership potential and talent throughgrowing and nurturing leadership habits andlearning with and from peers. This includesopportunities to take on new roles andexperiences, work shadowing and mentoring. Invitational leaders recognise that many groups– staff, children and young people, parents andthe community – have a stake in their schoolsand find ways to involve them in thedevelopment of the school’s collective visionand values. Leaders are confident and open enough toDaniel GolemanFocus: The Hidden Driver of Excellencedevelop high levels of trust, based on positiverelationships, leading to increased opportunitiesto draw upon specific knowledge and expertise,building collective capacity.‘Distributed leadership draws change from the everyday knowledge and capacities ofstaff rather than driving reforms through them. It is a crucial element in sustainableleadership. Distributed leadership is grounded in and advances a compelling moralpurpose’.Andy Hargreaves and Dennis Shirley - The Fourth WayThe Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

7Leadership Accountability forPerformance Leaders develop a robust, rigorous and Self-evaluation is grounded in accurate andtransparent self-evaluation process as part ofintelligent accountability to ensure that theirschools work effectively and efficiently towardsthe common good and the fullest developmentof their pupils. They welcome strong governancein holding them to account for the school’sperformance. Leaders accept accountability as part of‘Once a commitment is made, the goal will seemlarger, bolder, and more exciting leaders needto fix on it like a laser beam. They need to see itintensively, even obsessively. They feel it. Theyhear it. They taste it. They smell it. It becomespart of them, their very identity, because it issomething they are committed to make happen,come what may, whatever it takes’.Stephen DenningThe Secret Language of Leadershipdeveloping a performance culture, building intime for reviewing evidence and collectiveenquiry, constantly striving for betterment. Theymanage existing accountability systemsproactively and confidently and are willing to dothe hard things and make tough choices for thegreater good. They hold all staff to account fortheir professional conduct and practice. Leaders at all levels practise a continuous processhonest analysis and is used unflinchingly tocompare performance against the moststretching of benchmarks. Leaders practise 'appreciative enquiry' bydistinguishing the best of what is, fostering adialogue for knowledge around what should beand creating a vision for what will be promotingquestioning and creativity and a collectivementality for growth. Leaders regularly seek feedback, and take fullaccount of the views of staff, pupils, governors,parents and the community as a whole inevaluating progress and performance acceptingthe challenge of continuous improvement. Leaders make good use of external, criticalfriends including education consultants andpeer schools to provide a rigorous reality check.of reflection with their colleagues that becomesimplicit in all their work and learning, developingan accountability mindset, and acceptingresponsibility seeking a proper balance betweentrust and accountability. There is regular and forensic analysis ofperformance data and evidence informedpractice by leaders with exacting self-scrutinyand open discussion about strategies forimprovement and the implementation ofeffective action plans.‘The skill for a successful leader is to get the right balance between personalaccountability and the accountability of others. Ultimately what the leader does setsthe tone. Good leaders will take responsibility for results, are clear on how well theyare doing and how others are doing’.Andy Buck - What Makes a Great School?The Nine Pillars of Great School LeadershipThe Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership

8Leadership for Well-being Leaders develop well-being strategies and‘Nuance leaders have a curiosity about what ispossible, openness to other people, sensitivity tocontext and to loyalty to a better future. They seebelow the surface, enabling them to detectpatterns and their consequences for the system.They connect people to their own and each other’shumanity. They don’t lead they teach. They changepeople’s emotions, not just their minds. They havean instinct for orchestration. They foster sinews ofsuccess. They are humble in the face of challenges,determined for the group to be successful, andproud to celebrate success. They end updeveloping incredibly accountable organizationsbecause the accountability gets built into theculture. Above all, they are courageously andrelentlessly committed to changing the system forthe betterment of humanity’.Michael FullanNuance, Why Some Leaders Succeed and Others Fail Teachers, children and young people flourish inprogrammes as part of the overall culture of theschool and its values, fully integrated into the lifeand work of the school. Staff and pupils’ wellbeing is the result of a stimulating and inclusivelearning environment and meeting personalneeds and expectations. Leaders monitor carefully indicators of well-beingsuch as staff and pupil attendance, mental health,complaints and grievances, recruitment andretention and engagement and participation inschool life. They are open and transparent indiscussing well-being issues and seek feedbackthrough surveys and working groups. Leaders recognise that school environmentsshould be considered as an active part ofchildren and young people’s sense of belonging,where they can be confident they will fit in andsafe in their identity. Creating a sense of place,and emotional, rooted attachment to thelearning environment is vital to improvinglearning and well-being for every member of theschool community. Leaders build the best possible relationships,schools which foster their creativity, resilienceand sense of agency. Leaders bring a senseof hope, a sense of possibilities, a belief ineverybody and a recognition of the power ofplace and belonging. Leadership plays a key role in giving control andaffording participation in decision making.Professional growth,

Pillar 6 – Distributed and Invitational Leadership Pillar 7 – Leadership Accountability for Performance Pillar 8 – Leadership for Well-Being Pillar 9 – System Leadership The Nine Pillars of Great School Leadership ZA definition of leadership is to create the conditions for people to

Related Documents:

May 02, 2018 · D. Program Evaluation ͟The organization has provided a description of the framework for how each program will be evaluated. The framework should include all the elements below: ͟The evaluation methods are cost-effective for the organization ͟Quantitative and qualitative data is being collected (at Basics tier, data collection must have begun)

Silat is a combative art of self-defense and survival rooted from Matay archipelago. It was traced at thé early of Langkasuka Kingdom (2nd century CE) till thé reign of Melaka (Malaysia) Sultanate era (13th century). Silat has now evolved to become part of social culture and tradition with thé appearance of a fine physical and spiritual .

On an exceptional basis, Member States may request UNESCO to provide thé candidates with access to thé platform so they can complète thé form by themselves. Thèse requests must be addressed to esd rize unesco. or by 15 A ril 2021 UNESCO will provide thé nomineewith accessto thé platform via their émail address.

̶The leading indicator of employee engagement is based on the quality of the relationship between employee and supervisor Empower your managers! ̶Help them understand the impact on the organization ̶Share important changes, plan options, tasks, and deadlines ̶Provide key messages and talking points ̶Prepare them to answer employee questions

Dr. Sunita Bharatwal** Dr. Pawan Garga*** Abstract Customer satisfaction is derived from thè functionalities and values, a product or Service can provide. The current study aims to segregate thè dimensions of ordine Service quality and gather insights on its impact on web shopping. The trends of purchases have

Chính Văn.- Còn đức Thế tôn thì tuệ giác cực kỳ trong sạch 8: hiện hành bất nhị 9, đạt đến vô tướng 10, đứng vào chỗ đứng của các đức Thế tôn 11, thể hiện tính bình đẳng của các Ngài, đến chỗ không còn chướng ngại 12, giáo pháp không thể khuynh đảo, tâm thức không bị cản trở, cái được

Le genou de Lucy. Odile Jacob. 1999. Coppens Y. Pré-textes. L’homme préhistorique en morceaux. Eds Odile Jacob. 2011. Costentin J., Delaveau P. Café, thé, chocolat, les bons effets sur le cerveau et pour le corps. Editions Odile Jacob. 2010. Crawford M., Marsh D. The driving force : food in human evolution and the future.

Le genou de Lucy. Odile Jacob. 1999. Coppens Y. Pré-textes. L’homme préhistorique en morceaux. Eds Odile Jacob. 2011. Costentin J., Delaveau P. Café, thé, chocolat, les bons effets sur le cerveau et pour le corps. Editions Odile Jacob. 2010. 3 Crawford M., Marsh D. The driving force : food in human evolution and the future.