Cryptocurrency Mining

3m ago
215.47 KB
15 Pages
Last View : 11d ago
Last Download : n/a
Upload by : Vicente Bone

October 13, 2021The Honorable Kathy HochulGovernor of New York StateNYS State Capitol BuildingAlbany, NY 12224Re: Call for an environmental assessment of Proof-of-Work Cryptocurrency Mining in NYS and denial ofpermits for the Greenidge Generating Station and the Fortistar North Tonawanda FacilityDear Governor Hochul:We, the undersigned organizations, businesses, and labor groups, write today to urge your administrationto issue a statewide moratorium on Proof-of-Work (PoW) cryptocurrency mining until a thorough statewideGeneric Environmental Impact Statement (GEIS) is conducted, and to deny the permits for the GreenidgeGenerating Station and the Fortistar North Tonawanda Facility. These “mining” activities, particularlyProof-of-Work cryptocurrency mining use enormous amounts of energy to power the computers needed toconduct business – should this activity expand in New York, it could drastically undermine New York’sclimate goals established under the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act.Cryptomining is a relatively new technology that provides the basis for cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrenciessuch as Bitcoin are virtual currencies, which means they exist only online and there are no physical notesand coins. Cryptocurrencies also don’t belong to a central bank, meaning they have no government backing.They are international currencies and can be used to send money around the world without any identitychecks, making them a popular choice for cybercriminals involved in malicious or criminal activity. In theransomware attack on the Colonial pipeline, for example, the criminals were paid their “ransom” incryptocurrency.Digital currencies require authentication to prevent fraudulent transactions. PoW is the method that has themost significant energy demands. In PoW authentication, complex mathematical equations are assigned toeach transaction and miners compete to solve them. The first one to solve an equation authenticates thetransaction and wins currency for their effort. The equations can only be solved by brute force guesswork,so the person or company with the most computational power wins the most currency. With some currenciesvalued at over 48,000 a coin, albeit in a highly speculative market, a global digital gold rush is takingplace with hundreds of millions of computers competing for an edge in the market.In New York, data mining operations using warehouses full of computers have set up shop in upstate areassiphoning electricity from New York’s grid, “re-powering” defunct fossil-fueled power plants, thusseriously jeopardizing the state’s progress on and meeting mandates for reducing greenhouse gas (GHG)emissions. According to research from the New York Times, globally, Bitcoin mining consumes moreelectricity than the entire country of Ireland, which is almost 0.5% of all electricity consumptionworldwide. 11Other sources include: nt1

Additionally, there are very few jobs created by this industry, with profits accruing to the few, but theenvironmental impacts affect us all, particularly BIPOC communities that are often located near fossil fuelpower plants, and have been disproportionately affected by ongoing and legacy contamination.New York must halt this move to turn old fossil-fuel powered plants into cryptomining centers untila full environmental assessment is conducted on the impact that these operations will have ongreenhouse gas emissions, as well as the state’s air and water quality.There are at least two fossil-fueled power plants in New York, the Greenidge Generating Station and theFortistar North Tonawanda Facility, that serve as a test for New York State. We urge your administrationto deny the Title V Air Permits for these two facilities, as they do not comply with the state’s climatelaw.We were pleased to see Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Basil Seggos state that“Greenidge has not shown compliance with New York’s climate law,” and we entirely agree. The GHGemissions at the Greenidge Generating Station are skyrocketing. Greenidge’s current air permit allowsannual emissions of up to 641,878 tons of GHGs despite the fact that for the last ten years it emitted zeroemissions for six of those ten years, and emitted 119,207 tons of CO2 in 2018, 39,406 tons of CO2 in 2019,and 228,303 tons of CO2 in 2020.Additionally, the GHG emissions at the Fortistar North Tonawanda facility would further escalate shouldit become a Bitcoin Facility as has been proposed. As a power plant serving the grid, the power plant’sannual emissions were 12,448 tons of CO2 for 2018, 9,245 tons of CO2 for 2019, and 10,981 tons of CO2for 2020. As a Bitcoin mining facility, these emissions would skyrocket - the permit application states thatthe power plant’s potential CO2 emissions is estimated to be 339,068 tons per year, approximately thirtytimes its 2020 CO2 emissions. The plant is also estimating large increases in several other harmful copollutants including sulfur oxide, nitrous oxide, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter that will impactlocal air quality and public health.Most of the energy generated at these power plants will not go into the electrical grid. Instead, it is beingused by private technology companies where the financial rewards remain with the companies themselvesand their investors, while the environmental impacts are externalized, impacting our community, our state,and our ever-warming world.As you have witnessed in your early weeks on the job, the climate crisis in New York is here now. NewYork City recently saw unprecedented flooding that led to the loss of lives - strong climate action is needednow more than ever. We urge you to lead the way and set a national precedent on the issue of Proof-ofWork cryptocurrency by issuing a statewide moratorium and denying the permits for Greenidge andFortistar.Thank you for your time and consideration of our comments.Sincerely,2

1199 Service Employees International Union,United Healthcare Workers EastTodd HoblerExecutive Vice-PresidentCatskill MountainkeeperWes GillinghamAssociate Director350NYCDorian FulvioCattaraugus-Chautauqua for Clean WaterGlenn WahlCo-FounderAll Our EnergyGeorge PovallExecutive DirectorCayuga Lake Environmental Action NowJohn V. DennisPresidentAlliance for a Green EconomyAndra LeimanisCommunications & Outreach DirectorCayuga Lake Watershed NetworkHilary LambertSteward/Executive DirectorAnimals Are Sentient Beings, Inc.Sarah StewartPresidentChemung County Mother's Out FrontHeather M. StantonVolunteer Team CoordinatorAtchafalaya BasinkeeperDean WilsonExecutive DirectorCitizens' Climate Lobby - New York State LevelAction TeamBryan SwiftCo-Leader, CCL-NY State Level Action TeamAtlantic Chapter of the Sierra ClubKathryn BartholomewChapter ChairBear MeadowDwain WilderLuthierBillsboro WineryVinny Aliperti and Kim AlipertiOwnersBuffalo Niagara WaterkeeperJill JedlickaExecutive DirectorCampaign for Renewable EnergySara HessConvenerCitizens' Climate Lobby-RochesterKatie RyggCo-LeadCitizens' Environmental CoalitionBarbara WarrenDirectorCitizens to Preserve the Character ofSkaneatelesDessa BergenMemberCity of GenevaSteve ValentinoMayor1

Clean Air Coalition of Greater RavenaCoeymansBarbara HeinzenSteering Committee memberCouncil on Intelligent Energy & ConservationPolicy (CIECP)Michel LeeChairClean Air Coalition of Western New YorkEmily TerranaDirector of OrganizingCUNY School of Law Environmental JusticeCoalitionJill Sifah SigmanBoard member, EJCClimate Reality Finger Lakes ChapterThomas HirasunaChapter ChairClimate Reality ProjectJoseph PepeArchitectCoalition for Outreach, Policy & Education(COPE)Joseph WilsonCoordinatorCoastal Research & Education Society of LongIsland, Inc.Arthur H. Kopelman, Ph.D.PresidentColor Fairport GreenNatasha Besch-TurnerBoard MemberColorPenfieldGreenKatie RyggCo-LeadCommittee to Preserve the Finger LakesAbi BuddingtonBoard Member, SecretaryConcerned Health Professionals of New YorkCarmi OrensteinProgram DirectorDan Rapaport ConsultingDan RapaportOwnerDenizens of the BiosphereRegi TeasleyFounderDiocese of Central New YorkCharles GroverVoluntary PriestDr. Watson ElectricDebra WatsonOffice ManagerDryden Resouorce Awareness CoalitionJudith PierppontFounding MemberDryden Resource Awareness CoalitionMarie McRaeSpokespersonEarth Action, Inc.Mary GutierrezDirectorEarthjusticeMandy DeRocheDeputy Managing Attorney, Coal Program2

Energy Justice NetworkMike Ewall, Esq.Executive DirectorGas Free SenecaJoseph CampbellPresidentEnvironmental Action CoalitionKelly AndreuzziPresidentGlobal Justice Ecology ProjectTheresa ChurchAssistant DirectorEnvironmental Advocates NYConor BambrickDirector of Climate PolicyGrassroots Environmental EducationPatti WoodExecutive DirectorEnvironmental Justice Taskforce of the WNYPeace CenterCharley BowmanChairGreen Education and Legal FundMark DunleaChairEpiscopal Diocese of Central New YorkPatricia KinneyPriestFirst Unitarian Church of RochesterShari Halliday-QuanLead MinisterFood & Water WatchAlex BeauchampNortheast Region, LLCDiana WrightOwnerFormer EPA Regional AdministratorJudith EnckFossil Free TompkinsIrene WeiserCoordinatorFrackBustersNYMary FinneranCo-founderIndivisible Nassau CountySkylar BaderCo-LeaderKeuka Spring VineyardsLeonard WiltbergerOwnerKindred FareSusie AtvellOwnerLaw Office of Rachel TreichlerRachel TreichlerLawyerLEAD Agency, Inc.Earl HatleyGrand RiverkeeperLittle Lakes Sustainability NetworkTawn FeeneyLocal Progress NYKaren Mejia and Jennifer MecozziCo-Chairs3

Long Island Progressive CoalitionLisa TysonDirectorNew York Youth Climate LeadersMandy BerghelaCo-director of Governmental AffairsMilwaukee RiverkeeperCheryl NennRiverkeeperNew Yorkers for Clean PowerJen MetzgerSenior Policy AdvisorMothers Out Front New YorkLisa MarshallState Leadership TeamNY Climate Advocacy ProjectRuth FosterExecutive DirectorMothers Out Front TompkinsSheila OutOrganizing MemberMountain Rise United Church of ChristBill BrossChair of the Green Climate Action TeamNYCD16 IndivisibleNatalie PolvereCo-chair, Environment CommitteeNassau Hiking & Outdoor ClubGuy JacobConservation ChairNatural Resources Defense CouncilMarisa GuerreroAdvocacy CoordinatorNetwork for a Sustainable TomorrowAdam FlintDirector of Clean Energy ProgramsNew Paltz Climate Action CoalitionJess MullenChairpersonNew VinesTodd EichasOwner/PartnerNew York League of Conservation VotersReyna CohenState Policy AssociateNYPAN Environmental CommitteeCari GardnerChairNYPAN GreeneDonald GardnerCo-chairNYPIRGBlair HornerExecutive DirectorPAUSE - People of Albany United for SafeEnergyDiana WrightSecretaryPeconic BaykeeperPeter ToppingExecutive Director & BaykeeperPeople for a Healthy EnvironmentDoug CouchonPresidentPeople's Climate Movement - Capital RegionTina LiebermanChair4

Ravines Wine CellarsLisa HallgrenOwnerSaratoga-Warren-Washington ProgressiveActionJoeCo-chairRensselaer Environmental CoalitionRobert WeltonTreasurer on behalf of the Board of DirectorsSave the SoundTracy BrownRegional Director, Water ProtectionResidents Allied for the Future of Tioga (RAFT)Gerri WileyFacilitatorSeatuck Environmental AssociationEnrico NardoneExecutive DirectorResistSpectraRobert MayCoordinatorSeneca Lake GuardianYvonne TaylorVice PresidentReWild Long IslandPaul MerkelsonBoard SecretarySierra Club Niagara GroupSara SchultzChairRiverkeeperSean KellerSpecial Assistant to the PresidentSisters of Charity FederationTeresa KotturanMain NGO Representative at the UNRochester Area Interfaith Climate Action(RAICA)Sarah SingalMember, Steering Committee andCommunications CommitteeSol CenterHildur PalsdottirEducatorRockland Goes GreenSusan FreimanFounderSafe Energy Rights GroupNancy VannCo-founderSane Energy ProjectKim FraczekDirectorSolidarity Committee of the Capital DistrictSusan DuBoisTreasurerSouth Shore Audubon SocietyBrien WeinerPresidentSs. Peter and John Episcopal Church, Auburn,NYJohn RohdePriest in Charge5

St. James' Episcopal Church Vestry, Clinton,NYKatherine CollettJunior WardenThe Episcopal Church at Cornell, The Church ofthe Epiphany, TrumansburgTaylor DaynesPriestStone Quarry HouseNancy NortonPresidentTompkins County Climate Protection InitiativePeter BardaglioCoordinatorStop NY Fracked Gas PipelineRuth FosterBoard MemberTown of GenevaMark VenutiSupervisorStop the Algonquin Pipeline Expansion (SAPE)Suzannah GliddenCo-founderTransition Town Port WashingtonMargaret GalbraithFacilitatorStopCricketValley.orgBill KishFounding OrganizerUlster Activists of Ulster CountyKristin BrownMemberSustainable Tompkins, Inc.Gay NicholsonPresidentUnited for ActionLing TsouCo-founderSyracuse DSA EcosocialistsAmber RutherMemberUnited For Clean EnergyTina BongarCommunity OrganizerSyracuse Peace CouncilCarol BaumOrganizerUpper Allegheny Waterkeeper-affiliatePamela DigelWaterkeeperThe Climate Reality Project: Capital Region,NY ChapterLaura FaulkChapter Co-ChairUptown Progressive Action, a NYPAN chapterTing BarrowMember of Steering CommitteeThe Climate Solutions Accelerator of theGenesee-Finger Lakes RegionKristen Van HoorewegheDirector of Collaborative ActionVeterans for Climate JusticeColleen BolandFounder/U.S. Air Force (Retired)Waterkeepers ChesapeakeRobin BroderDeputy Director6

WESPAC Foundation, Inc.Nada KhaderExecutive DirectorXRA RochesterLinda EdwardsCoordinatorWestchester Alliance for Sustainable SolutionsCourtney WilliamsCo-founderZion Episcopal Church of Windsor NYGeoffrey DoolittleParish PriestSENECA LAKE GUARDIAN BUSINESS COALITION:12th Moon Astrology17th Century SudsA Holism In SyncA Stone’s Throw B&BAbelson Law OfficeAcorn DesignsAdmiral Peabody’s Lakeside LodgingAdvanced RemodelingAiry Acres VineyardAKS Apartments, LLCAligned Business ConceptsAmazing Grace Bed & BreakfastAmerican Canoe Association, Atlantic DivisionAnn Cain Crusade, R.N., M.S., L.AcAnn Sheldon, Life CoachAnother Time AntiquesApplegate ToysArea RecordsArgetsinger VineyardsAtwater VineyardsAutumn Leaves Used BooksB&B: 448 East Broadway LLCBagley’s Poplar Ridge VineyardBarnstormer WineryBarry Family VineyardsBear Meadow Folk InstrumentsBeef N’ BrewBella Stone MassageBellwether CideryBenedict Accounting and Tax ServiceBerta’s CafeBill Carini GardensBillsboro WineryBitterwind Hop FarmBl.inkBlackberry Inn B&BBlecher ElectricBloomer Creek VineyardBoathouse Beer GardenBob and DeeBob and June’s Organic CoffeeBostwick House B&BBottomless BrewingBoundary Breaks VineyardBout Time B & BBramble: Community HerbalismBread ’N’ RosesBrian Grafstein LMTBrian Keeler, ArtistBumble & Co. B & BBunnell AssociatesBurdett House B&BBurford BooksBuried Treasures Organic FarmButtonwood Creek Tree FarmCalm ReflectionsCamp Seneca LakeCappy’sCapricorn Hill FarmsCaptain Bill’s & Seneca Harbor StationCash and Caring Auction ServicesCastle Creek KombuchaCatherine CottagesCathy Emilian DesignCayuga Chiropractic & WellnessCayuga Morning Star B & B7

Caywood VineyardsCharles Limousine ServiceChateau Lafayette ReneauChefs for the MarcellusCherry Orchard B & BChurch Creative Flooring, Inc.Cindy Lane-Newcomb; Raven’s LandingClean TeamClear Path Healing Arts CenterClimbing Bines Hop Farm and BreweryCloud 9 WellnessCompost InternationalCortland Beer Company, LLCCottage Views B & BCotton Club at the WindmillCowlick FarmsCreating ChangeCreativelink Photo/Graphics ServicesCreekside CafeCrestwood Pools Inc.Crooked Lake WineryCummins NurseryCurry Creek VineyardsCustom Care PharmacyD. Bordwell Editorial ServicesDamiani Wine CellarsDan Rapaport ConsultingDano’s HeurigerDaphne’s DelightsDarlene Bordwell PhotographyDavid Mooney-State Farm InsuranceDeep Lake IndustriesDeMarco VineyardsDerek’s DinerDewitt Park InnDigital WiresDiscovery MassageDixie O’Connor, Fine ArtsDown to Earth MarketsDr. Konstantin Frank Vinifera Wine CellarsDS Hoffman, LuthierDundee Scottish Festival of the Finger LakesEagle Crest Vineyards/ O-Neh-Da VineyardEarthgirl FlowersEarthgirl PotteryEast Side Dog ServicesEchoes of the Glen B & BEdible Finger LakesEli Thomas ArtEly Fruit FarmsEmery VineyardsEminence Road Farm WineryEnigma Skin Care StudioEremita WineryEve’s CideryEvolving StudiosExercise EnterpriseFactivistFaith Muirhead, Educational ConsultantFarm KindFarmer Ground FlourFarmshed CNYFinger Lakes Clean Waters Initiative, IncFinger Lakes ConciergeFinger Lakes DistillingFinger Lakes Estate and Auction CompanyFinger Lakes FloristFinger Lakes FoieFinger Lakes Food Company, LLCFinger Lakes Gifts and LoungeFinger Lakes Mill Creek CabinsFinger Lakes Natural HealthFinger Lakes Soap CompanyFinger Lakes Transport and ToursFinger Lakes Vacation RentalFinger Lakes Waterfall ResortFinger Lakes Website ServicesFingerlakes Angling Zone Guide ServiceFingerLakes1.comFirehouse DistilleryFleur De Lys of the Finger LakesFLX TableFLX WineryForever Green Tree Care ServicesForge CellarsFork & Gavel Cafe at CornellFossil and TillFox Pond Products2

Fox Trot StablesFree Spirit Design GlassFree to Be Me Coalition for PeaceFrisch KitchenFrog Hollow MarinaFrontenac Point Vineyard and WineryFruit Yard WineryGeneva Bicycle CenterGentle Giants B&BGentlyBorne MidwiferyGeorge’s ProsoundGil’s HoneybeesGimme! Coffee Inc.Ginger Cat B&BGlacier Ridge VineyardsGlen Mountain MarketGlendale FarmsGlenhaven Farm WineryGlenora Wine CellarsGlobal TacoGolden Knight Inn & SuitesGolden Orb Tattoos and PiercingsGood Earth Health FoodsGood Karma CandlesGood to Go! MarketGoose Watch WineryGraceful Arts Fiber StudioGRACES (Grass Roots AccomodationsCoalition for Energy Sustainability)Graphic ConnectionsGreensprings Natural CemeteryGreenStar Cooperative MarketGryphon ConstructionHalsey’s Wood Fire BistroHarvest CafeHayward House B&BHazelnut KitchenHazlitt 1852 VineyardsHeart & Hands Wine CompanyHeart to Heart YogaHeavily Brewing CompanyHector Logging CompanyHector Wine Co.Hemlock Hills Alpaca FarmHermann J. Wiemer VineyardHeron Hill WineryHipshot Products, Inc.Hotel GrotonHumble Hill Farm and LodgeHunt Country VineyardsIdol Ridge WineryIleen Kaplan Piano ServiceIndian Creek FarmInner DecisionsInterludesInternational Climbing MachinesIrish CarpentryItaly Hill ProduceIthaca Acupuncture- Integrative MedicineCenterIthaca Soap/17th Century SudsIthacaDomains.comJ & D Landscape ConstructionJabberwockJCC of Greater RochesterJeremy and Erica CrytzerJesi Turner, MusicianJoe’s HotsJoseph M Rao Inc.Journeyman ServicesJR Dill WineryJust a Few Acres FarmJust DessertsKali HerbsKate Gustin, CPC - Joy of Living Health andLife CoachKeep in Touch Therapeutic MassageKeuka Artisan Bakery & DeliKing Ferry WineryKing’s Garden VineyardsKingbird FarmKirton’s Farm MarketKnapp WineryKrys Cail, Farm and Food BusinessDevelopment ConsultingKurtz ConstructionLake City HobbyLakehouse B&B3

Lakeland WineryLakeside Refrigeration ServiceLamoreaux Landing Wine CellarsLarson PublicationsLawrence Reverby - Attorney at LawLeaf Kitchen RestaurantLeidenfrost VineyardsLilly BroadcastingLinda Parks, CPA and Financial AdvisorLinda Ruth AstrologyLive Well Upstate: Massage Therapy andNatural MedicineLocke’s Glen, LLC Vacation RentalsMacro MamasMagnolia Place B & BMain Street Bike ShopManndible Cafe at Cornell/ Fork and Gavel Cafeat CornellMarmalade Cat B & BMcGregor WineryMedleys Cafe & CateringMichael Turback-Food and Wine WriterMoon Heart StudiosMoosewood RestaurantMother Earth Natural FoodsMuddy Fingers FarmNative Plant NurtureNatural Health Family ChiropracticNautical Nights B & BNewell FarmNo Man ServicesNorth East Organic Farming Assoc. of NYNortheast Band SupplyNorthstar Public HouseO’Shaughnessy Antiques and Fine Arts GalleryOdessa Coffee DepotOld Fashioned Flowers from Fernville FarmOwl Gorge ProductionsParadise on the Lake B and BParker’s GrillePassport CreationsPenguin Bay WineryPerennial Evolution FarmPeter Drobny - Glass ConsultantPi TruckPine Tree FarmsPioneer PrintingPlowbreak FarmPompous Ass WineryPreliminaires ChocolatPrivacy on the Lake B & BQuality Wine ToursQWIK SolarQwikSolarRasta Ranch VineyardsRavines Wine CellarsReagan’s Canoe and Kayak LiveryReality RealtyRed Dove TavernRed Jacket OrchardsRed Newt CellarsRegional AccessRelax InnRENOVUS Energy, Inc.Rising Sun ReikiRobinia Redux Locust Fencepost PlantationRooster Fish BrewingRoots and Wings Performing Arts AcademyRustic Log CabinsSabol FarmSalubrious FarmsSapsquatch Pure Maple ProductsSawmill Creek VineyardsSchank CompaniesSeneca BioEnergySeneca Chief Guide ServicesSeneca General StoreSeneca Harbor StationSeneca Harbor Wine CenterSeneca Lake General StoreSeneca Lake Vacation RentalsSeneca LodgeSeneca Lodge Craft BrewingSeneca Lodge Lake HouseSeneca Physical Therapy of the Finger Lakes,PCSeneca Sailing AdventuresSeneca Shore Wine Cellars4

Seneca Springs ResortSeneca Strategic Consulting, LLCSeneca Sunrise CoffeeSeneca Wine Boat ToursSenecaLakeVacationRentals.comSenecayuga Properties, LLC.September Hill MidwiferyShalestone VineyardsShaw VineyardsSheldrake Point VineyardsShowboat Motel and RestaurantSilver Springs WinerySilver Thread VineyardsSix Circles FarmSkyland GallerySkyland Guest HouseSnug Planet and Snug SolutionsSolar Systems UnlimitedSouthern Tier HopsSquires Accounting and Tax Services Inc.Stalks and StonesStanding Stone VineyardStaving Artist WoodworkStick and Stone FarmStomping GroundsStone Pillow PotteryStoneBoat Computing SolutionsStonecat CafeStony Lonesome Farms LLCStudio Westsubject2change MediaSummit to Stream AdventuresSun Dance CreationsSun Garden GrilleSunrise Hill VineyardsSunrise Landing B & BSunset on Seneca B&BSunshine Natural FoodsSustainable Viticulture Systems-ProprietorSuzanne’s Fine Regional CuisineSwamp Road BasketsSwedish Hill, Goose Watch, and Penguin BayWineriesSweet Chariot LiverySweet Mother NatureTabora VineyardsTAITEM Engineering PCTchotchkeThe Black Sheep InnThe Burns SistersThe Elf in the OakThe Good Life FarmThe Keep at Newell FarmThe Last WordThe Pearl of Seneca Lake B & BThe PiggeryThe Soap GardenThe Water CottageThe White GazeboThemis and ThreadThink TopographyThomas Merrill Professional Land SurveyorThree Brothers WineriesThree Swallows FarmThree Tree Inn B & BThunder Mountain FoodsThyme Stands Still Fruit and VegetablesTim McKinney,Photographer/Writer/WoodworkerTim ReganTim Wells- Furniture MakerTom BlecherTom WeidemannTree Gate FarmTurbo TaxiTwo Goats BrewingTwo Sisters Cottage on Seneca LakeUnique Pool ServiceUpstate Energy SolutionsVaping BadVentosa VineyardsVilla BellangeloWaterloo ContainerWaterloo Custom Apparel and GiftsWatkins Glen MassageWatkins Glen Wine and SpiritsWayne SchutzWest Haven Farm5

West Main KitchenWest Side Wine and SpiritsWhite Gazebo InnWhite Wizard Consulting, LLCWide Awake BakeryWild Flower CafeWine a Bit and MoreWine ForwardWine on IceWixom FarmWolf Tree FarmZero to Go LLCFINGER LAKES WINE BUSINESS COALITION (FLXWBC) MEMBERS:Amazing Grace Bed & Breakfast Est. 1999Argetsinger Vineyards Est. 1996Atwater Estate Vineyards Est. 1999A Stone’s Throw Bed & Breakfast Est. 2012Backacres Vineyard Est. 1947Bagley’s Poplar Ridge Vineyards Est. 1980Barnstormer Winery Est. 2013Barry Family Cellars Est. 2011Bellangelo Est. 2002Billsboro Winery Est. 2007Black Diamond Farm, LLC Est. 1994Bloomer Creek Vineyard Est. 1999Bostwick House B&B Est. 2007Boundary Breaks Vineyard Est. 2008Bully Hill Vineyards Est. 1970Ann Cain Crusade Acupuncture and HerbalMedicine Est. 2006Castel Grisch Winery Est. 1986Catherine Cottages Est. 2003Cherry Orchard B & B Est. 1988Clean Team Est. 2000Climbing Bines Craft Ale Co. and Hop FarmEst. 2013Compost International Est. 2010Costello, Cooney & Fearon, PLLC Est. 1896Cottage Views Bed & Breakfast Est. 2013Curry Creek Vineyards Est. 2003Damiani Wine Cellars Est. 2000Damiani Vineyards Est. 1997Dan Rapaport Consulting Est. 1982Davis Vineyard Est. 1998Dr. Frank’s Vinifera Wine Cellars Est. 1962Echoes of the Glen Bed & Breakfast Est. 2005Eli Thomas Art Est. 1990Eminence Road Farm Winery Est. 2008Eremita Winery Est. 2011Experience! The Finger Lakes Est. 2007Eve’s Cidery Est. 2002Fall Bright, The Wine Makers Shoppe Est. 1978Finger Lakes Cider House Est.2014Finger Lakes Food Company LLC, dba. VerjoozEst. 2009Finger Lakes Mill Creek Cabins Est. 2006Finger Lakes Solar Co-op Est. 2014First Flight Est. 1987FLX Wienery Est. 2014Forge Cellars Est. 2008Frontenac Point Vineyard – Estate Winery Est.1979Ginger Cat Bed & Breakfast Est. 2008Ginny Lee Cafe Est. 1983Good for Business Est. 1999Goose Watch Winery Est. 1997Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards, Inc. Est. 1985Heart & Hands Wine Company Est. 2006Hector Wine Company Est. 2009Hermann J. Wiemer Vineyards Est.1979Heron Hill Vineyard Est. 1977Hidden Marsh Distillery Est. 2007Hosmer Winery Est. 1985Hunt Country Vineyard Est. 1981Idol Ridge Winery Est. 2013Ingle Vineyard Est. 1972Inspire Moore Winery and Vineyard Est. 2007Interludes Est. 2000Italy Hill Produce Est. 2009J. Crytzer Woodworking Est. 2003J.R. Dill Winery Est. 2009Keuka Spring Vineyards Est. 19856

King Ferry makers of Treleaven Wines Est.1984Lacey Magruder Vineyard & Winery Est. 2011Lake House & Cottage Rental Est. 1997Lakeshore Winery Est. 1982Lamoreaux Landing Wine Cellars Est. 1990Loan Chiropractic Est. 1986Locke’s Glen, LLC Vacation Rentals Est. 2015Lost Kingdom Brewery Est. 2014Macro Mamas Est. 1992Magnolia Place Bed & Breakfast Est. 1997McGregor Vineyard Est. 1971Medleys Est. 1993Montezuma Winery Est. 2001Nautical Nights Est. 2000Nedloh Brewing Company Est. 2014New Vines Bed & Breakfast Est. 2007Northside Wine and SpiritsNYSP2I Est. 2005Old Fashioned Flowers, Fernville Farm Est.2011O-Neh-Da & Eagle Crest Vineyards Est. 1872Peggy Haine – Food and Wine Writer Est. 1984Penguin Bay Winery Est. 2006Pompous Ass Winery Est. 2008Ports of New York, Est. 2000Rasta Ranch Vineyards Est. 1993Ravines Wine Cellar Est. 2000Redbyrd Orchard Cider Est.2010Red Newt Cellars, Inc. Est. 1998Regional Access Est. 1989Renovus Energy Est. 2003Robinia Redux Locust Fence Post PlantationEst. 1979Sawmill Creek Vineyard Est. 1852Savor Life Radio Est. 1994Seneca 7 Est. 2011Shalestone Vineyards, LLC Est. 1995Shaw Vineyard Est. 1980Sheldrake Point Winery Est. 1997Silver Springs Winery LLC Est. 2001Silver Thread Vineyard Est.1991South Hill Cider Est. 2013Stone Boat Computing Est. 2011Stone Cat Cafe Est. 1999Stone Pillow Pottery Est. 2012Stoney Lonesome Farm, LLC Est. 2012Strategic Coaching Est. 2014Sun Dance Creations Est. 1998Sunrise Landing Bed and Breakfast Est. 2004Sustainable Viticulture Systems Est. 2013Suzanne Fine Regional Cuisine Est. 2003Swedish Hill Vineyard, Inc. Est. 1985Themis and Thread Est.2013The OCD Art Galley Est. 2013The Pearl of Seneca Lake, Inc. Est. 2005Three Brothers Wineries and Estates Est. 2007The Rose Petal Inn Est. 2014Two Goats Brewing Est. 2010Ventosa Vineyards Est. 2005Vineyard View Winery Est. 2013Wagner Valley Brewing Company Est. 1997Wagner Vineyards Est.1976Wide Awake Bakery Est. 20102

1 . October 13, 2021 . The Honorable Kathy Hochul . Governor of New York State . NYS State Capitol Building . Albany, NY 12224 . Re: Call for an environmental assessment of Proof-of-Work Cryptocurrency Mining in NYS and denial of