CIP-014 Critique MPSCon
CIP-014 CritiqueMPSConFrank R. McElvain, PE, St. Paul, MNRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Nov 11, 2015usa.siemens.com/em
Disclaimer My opinionsare my ownRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 22015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
What is CIP-014? NERC has a collection of ReliabilityStandards divided into a dozenreliability categories that apply to a dozen registered functionalentities. One classification family:CIPaddresses Critical InfrastructureProtection Mostly cyber assets and security CIP-014 is an exception as itaddresses physically energizedhigh voltage assets. Driven by recent substationincidents.Restricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 32015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
CIP-014 OrganizationFirst HalfSecond HalfElectric FocusPhysical FocusDetermine the Substation’selectric system criticalitySecure the critical substationRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 42015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
Electric Studies:What does the Standard Primarily Require? Stations which require study: All 500 kV and higherThree or more 345 kVTwo 345 and one or more 230 kVOne 345 kV and three or more 230 kVFive or more 230 kV Have a methodology Follow Your Methodology Have an Independent Third PartyVerify your work.Restricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 52015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
What are the Elements of a ComprehensiveEvaluation? An analysis of each Stage Evaluate how the fault condition will progress through clearing Evaluate how the recovery will occur through the point when normaloperation is reestablished.Restricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 62015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
What are the Elements of a ComprehensiveEvaluation? An analysis of each Stage Evaluate how the fault condition will progress through clearing Evaluate how the recovery will occur through the point when normaloperation is reestablished. Contingency Stage Remote or Delayed Clearing 20 Cycles or more Entire SubstationRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 72015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
What are the Elements of a ComprehensiveEvaluation? An analysis of each Stage Evaluate how the fault condition will progress through clearing Evaluate how the recovery will occur through the point when normaloperation is reestablished. Contingency Stage Remote or Delayed Clearing 20 Cycles or more Entire Substation Recovery Stage How long is the recovery stage? There are actually two recovery stagesRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 82015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
Replacement/Repair TimesMajor Substation EquipmentDamaged StationEquipmentBusCircuit BreakersSwitchesCurrent TransformersOther SwitchgearPower TransformersCooling RadiatorsSurge ArrestersWeeks to Replace4812O PO1620Most LikelyO2428323640444852566064PPO PO POMost LikelyPO POPO: OptimisticP: PessimisticMcElvain, F. Siemens PTI, (Electricity Today Online April / May 2015), Transmission Planning: Protecting the Physical Security of the Power ricity-today/et april may 2015 digital/2015051401/#50Restricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 92015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
Key Dynamic Factors Initial fault accelerates nearbygeneration units Loss of transmission reduces thesystem’s ability to absorb pent-upenergy Changes the unit’s critical clearingtimeRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 102015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
Recovery P (V1V2/x) sinδP (V1V2/x) sinδ12108SystemG642004590135180Restricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 112015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
Conclusions Real-time is not when you want to discover a unit stability limit exists Define helpful operating procedures N-1 in recovery stage is needed Power Flow Evaluation Full station out and next N-1 Transformers out and next N-1 Dynamics Full station out and critical N-1 at generation If necessary, transformer out and next N-1 Evaluate the fault conditionRestricted Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 122015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
ContactFrank McElvain, PESenior Manager, Consulting4000 Third AvenueFoster City, CA 94404Mobile: (408) 239 ain, F. Siemens PTI, (Electricity TodayOnline April / May 2015), Transmission Planning:Protecting the Physical Security of the electricitytoday/et april may 2015 d Siemens AG 2015 All rights reserved.Page 132015-XX-XXAuthor / Department
What is CIP-014? NERC has a collection of Reliability Standards divided into a dozen reliability categories that apply to a dozen registered functional entities. One classification family:CIP addresses Critical Infrastructure Protection Mostly cyber assets and security CIP-014
CIP -003 -5, CIP -004 -5, CIP -005 -5, CIP -006 -5, CIP -007 -5, CIP -008 -5, CIP -009 -5, CIP -010 -1, . controls to mitigate risk to BES Cyber Systems. This suite of CIP Standards is referred to as the Version 5 CIP Cybe r Security Standards . Most requirement s open with , Each Responsible Entity shall implement one or more documented .
CIP-005-5 . 4/1/2016: CIP-006-5. 4/1/2016: CIP-007-5. 4/1/2016: CIP-008-5. 4/1/2016: CIP-009-5. 4/1/2016: CIP-010-1. 4/1/2016: CIP-011-1. 4/1/2016: Talk with Texas RE & NRWG February 18, 2016. 3 CIP
(CIP 005 and CIP 006) g, g ( ) Replacement of 500 signs and 3,000 chain markers (CIP 020) Rehabilitation of 5,000 feet of track pads/shock absorbers (CIP 021) Rehabilitation of 5 miles of third rail (CIP 023) Rehabilitation of 10 miles of running rail (CIP 024)Rehabilitati
NERC CIP-014. Compliance Guide. The purpose of the NERC CIP-014 reliability standard is to protect electrical . facilities from physical attacks that could threaten the stability and operation of the electric grid distribution system. Requirement R5 man
CIP-014 Risk Assessment Agreement May 16, 2022 2 CAISO/DAL 05/16/2022 1.0 Introduction RC West was formed in 2019, and one of the services offered in Section 19 of the CAISO tariff is to provide a risk assessment verification as required by the North . NERC in the future for the CIP-014 risk assessment verification. The balance of the
2.3 What is the best way to develop a cIP? 19 2.3.1 Compile and disseminate a situation analysis 19 2.3.2 Convene a cIP workshop 20 2.3.3 Align cIP goals and objectives with broader national health plans 24 2.3.4 Draft the five-year strategic cIP, including annual operational plan 27 2.3.5 Conduct a planning and budgeting exercise 28 3 The continuous Improvement Plan (cIP) content 3.1 .
Version 5 builds on CIP-002-4 and previous drafts of CIP-010 & 011 Use similar content structure and terminology as previous CIP Standards (CIP-002 through CIP-009) August 24, 2011 CSO706 SDT Webinar 5. Development Goals Goal 1: To address the remaining
influence of ideological values on the policies and practices of America’s criminal justice systems. Recently, however, a trend toward critical analysis of the behavior of police, courts, and corrections has emerged that focuses exclusively on ideology as the analytical tool of choice. For example, Barlow (2000), and Bohm and Haley (2001) include extensive discussion of the influence of .
