Ann Miracle, Ph.D.

United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Official Hearing ExhibitProgress Energy Florida, Inc.In the Matter of:(Levy County Nuclear Power Plant, Units 1 and 2)ASLBP #: 09-879-04-COL-BD01Docket #: 05200029 05200030Exhibit #: NRC060-00-BD01Identified: 10/31/2012Admitted: COLNPEm e, Ann L [ann.miracle@pnl.gov]Wednesday, March 09, 2011 5:21 PMMasnik, Michael; Miller, Beverly MScherpelz, Robert I; Bruner, DouglasFWS info for manateesmanatee aerial surveys 2006 to 2011.pdfHi Mike, The attached is a fax I received from Joyce Kleen at the Chassahowitzka National Wildlife Refuge in Crystal River, FL. She does the aerial surveys for manatees within the area, and provided the aerial survey results from 2006 to present. This definitely helps us with assessing impacts to manatees in showing roughly how many frequent the areas in question for the LNP project. Bev, this needs to be docketed. Thanks! Ann Miracle, Ph.D.Staff ScientistEnvironmental Assessment Pacific Northwest National Laboratory 902 Battelle Boulevard P.O. Box 999, MSIN K3-61 Richland, WA 99352 USA Tel: 509-372-4327 Ann.Miracle@pnl.gov www.pnl.gov ((( (" 1NRC060June 26, 2012

Hearing Identifier:Email Number:Levy County COL NonPublic3731Mail Envelope 4ED97)Subject:Sent Date:Received Date:From:FWS info for manatees3/9/2011 5:21:02 PM3/9/2011 5:21:07 PMMiracle, Ann LCreated By:ann.miracle@pnl.govRecipients:"Scherpelz, Robert I" scherpelz@pnl.gov Tracking Status: None"Bruner, Douglas" Douglas.Bruner@nrc.gov Tracking Status: None"Masnik, Michael" Michael.Masnik@nrc.gov Tracking Status: None"Miller, Beverly M" Beverly.Miller@pnl.gov Tracking Status: NonePost Office:EMAIL05.pnl.govFilesSizeMESSAGE795manatee aerial surveys 2006 to 2011.pdfOptionsPriority:Return Notification:Reply Requested:Sensitivity:Expiration Date:Recipients Received:StandardNoNoNormalDate & Time3/9/2011 5:21:07 PM188389

FaxCfiassafiowitzlig :Nationa{Wi[d{ife fuge Compf"e:x:.Ch:l sabowitzkal'Iational"Wildlifc Refuge" Crystal Riyer National \Vildlifc Refuge'/: Egmollt ational \Vildlifc RefugePassage Key ational Wildlife Refuge Pinellas ;.'\l"ational Wildlife Refuge1502 SE Kings Bay Dr" Cr:. . stal River, FL 34429PHO}:'S: (352) 563-2088 FAX: (352) 795-7961To: ,rac\("Fax Number:50913,5 -do19From:--::::r""10 Date:3 \ '6 \ \ \Pages to fOllow:Subject:Did you kno,y that the U,S. Fish and \ViJdlife Setvkc . 1ll3.llJ.g s 93-:n:l1ion c e :"\aticr.nl \'ii:di:(", Re:'Jf;.e Systt lllof more tln.l 548 r.atic;!\ wil';'lifc r,f\l& : Y- \ e.e " oocrm 66I::ltio ]j i . \Eltch ricsCL".d 78 ccologiciJlc(lr.lp iscdservic sIIdesliO\r. (l t, cnf()rc s Fed rnl re lClres o"i! :Ilife \(\'.'is1\.z." a \ VI """,-'1-- .9 ''')e\ '-:TI'S CO\,.-:-'\ 1 1n:lliQna:ly signitlcRnt fi,he;i !s CQ'l;:erVi!S il.1d restores wildlif.\vitil their cons r,; ",I;Oll , ff[\rtsh blt :at:d ht;ps fN igr,&Qv rnlll n

, ':::,.',-,'R'a-l' i r1!J-;P,'l"!l'!!I!iI'17t't[:rFaxCfiassafiowitzRg :Nationa{Wi{d{ife fuge Compfe:x:.Ch:l S:lbowitzka0.-ational Viiildlife Refuge" Cry tal River National \Vildlifc Refuge'/: Egmont ational \Vildlife RefugePassage Key ational Wildlife Refuge" Pinellas )l"ational Wildlife Refuge1.502 SE Kings Bay D,,, CI).'stal River, FL 34429PHO}:E: (352) 563-2088 FAX: (352) 795-7961To:Did you know that the U,S. Fish and \Vildlife Se['\'kc .Fax Number: ma.ll:tg '93 :n:l1ionac e:-;atiOf.,1l \'.'i:d,:fe Re:'J .e Systel11CQI;lp i scdof more tiu.l1 548 r. ;J.tiG .;!l wilClifc rCf\IE .:oFrom: oocrm 60;io.t'C )j i :-. :ntc!l ricsr .d 7S ccologicnl services lide (8'.:O Date:Pa.ges to follow:Subject:1\"" 4 a\M """,-'1- .9 Sec''»''', ,cTI'S'd-C0 1",-",\;;q\ re tores ;;:Q ::erV 5, vitil theirC',," n:ttiona:ly sign:tlcantfish ;i !sil.1d restores wildlifi; O:l,U\-'",ljOll ffortsh blt :w:d hc;ps rot igr.r::.ov rnlll r.

AERIAL )J.L u"'JATEE COUI\lSTOT .\LT (C)KJ3CRY05JA-'111 465(66) 353(50) 38(4)19JANll 453(70) 365(61) 42(3)24JMll' 541(73) 408(59) 12(2)02FEBll Cancelled due to fog16FEBII 423(53) 321(40) 48(8)OIMARII' 48( 4)25( 3) 6DAT&SURVEY LOCATIO;-lSpp!,HOM SRUHQ (1) S0014X7(1)X15(1)X4B 0002011WAC \'lIT S\VR SREXXXXXXXX003(1) 05(1) 047XX6(1) XSUlllina",").;0 Surv yTotal of all ma.:::atees; adults calvesCalvesKings BayCI'}'stal River"C"HOM: Upper Homosassa. RiverLHQ)'f: Lower Homosassa RiverSR: Satt Rive.PP: Crystal River Nuclear Power PlantDischarge Canal\VAC: \Vaccasassa Bay ar.d River\'.fIT: \\'ithlacoochee Rive;"BC: Barge CanalSWR: S\:wannee RiverSRE: Suwa::mee RiVeT EstuaryCH: ChassahO\vitzkn River EstuaryWW: We-eki \Vachee Rive:Highest survey count was.Largest # in :Kings Bay wasLargest "# of calves wasLargest # in Up. Homosassa wasLargest #- in Crysml Rive:' was1 Statewide Synoptic Man.'ltec Aeri"l SUI ley.: State\vide )"1anatee Abu.ndance Survey-special survey-no: a complete refuge surveyInforma ionprovidea by U,S. Fish and \Vildli:e Serv'ice, Crys:al River, FLX0X0CH \\"V/XXXX5(1) 8(1 )XXXX

'r:. .-,-rAERIAL MAi'lATEE COU'lTS - 2010SL'RVEY LOCATIO STOTALpp BC 'WAC WIT SWR SRE CH V/\VI (C)KB q y UHOM LHO)'f SR323(25) 258(20) 064(5)00XXXXXX0113JA}'H0 1 65,(99) 566(91) 076(8)010000143020JA'-1"lO 548(74) 437(60) 12(1) 68(7)14(4) 7(2) 100XXXXXX03FEB1O 430(36) 286(26) 6(1) 54(5)XXX417(2) 63(2) 0XXX120(13) 217FEBIO 625(49) 498(36) 2XXXX030XXXO':MAR10 419(33) 256(20) 1153(11) 12(1) 6(1) 0XXXXX19MARIO 279(41) 168(24) 261(11) 11 (4)34(2) 0XXXXXX331 Lo.RlO 226(28) 123(14)62(10) 19(3)3(1 ) 16XXXXXX30lLAPRIO 55(12) 40(10) 011 (;) 2XXXXX02(1) 0X2SAPRiO 114(17) 69(11) 18(3) 9(2)XX23(1) XXXX94X12MAY10 73(13) 40( 8)4(1)6(2)01X18(2) X13XXOSrCNIO73( 6) 39( 3)98(1)29(1)X0XXX5(1) X123JU}.'lOS7( 9) 48( 5) 11(1) 6(1)9(1)XXS( l ) XX302X07J1JLIO82(11) 37( .:)7(1) 14(2)12(3)XXX6(1) X303XX21JCLIO41 ( 4) 27( :)I4(1)0XXX9(2) X0004(2)04AUGIO 55(10) 14( 3)202(1) 8(1) 6(1)37(1) 09(1)002XXXXISAUGI0 30( 4) 17( 3)330II3(1 ) XX02SEPIO19( 3) 16( 2)2(1) 001X00XXXX7(2)0X15SEPIO22( 4)9( 2)3030XXXXX29SEPIO2(1)44( 6) 36( 5)I2XXXXX300X;l30CTlO47(10) l5( 9)XXXXXX1SCI)101XX170CTlO59(10) 44( 8)4(1)22(1) XXXX43010KOVI0 293(33) 166(23)37(6) 12(3)XX270(1) 0XXXX624):[OV10 117(15) 63( 9) 15(2) 7(2)4(1) 1216(1) 0XXXXXXXIODECIO 621(53) 516(48)375(5)027X0XXXX0X23DEClO 506(44) 441(39)853(5)3010XXXXXKev:Summa,",':X, No SurveyHighest 3urvey count was 651 On JanuaI)' 13, 2010.T, Total of all manatees; adul:s calves(C); CalvesLargest # ir. Kings Ba:y was 566 Oil January 13, 1010.DATE06JA" 10KB: Kings BayCRY:LrIOM:LHO::\1:SR:C:ystal Riv.: rUpper Homosassa RiverLo\ver Homosassa Rh'erSalt Riverpp; Crystal River Nuclear PO\ver PlamDischarge CanalWAC: Viaeeasass;} Bay and RiverWTI; \\'i .hlacooc:'1ee RiverBC: Barge Cana:S\VR: Suwannee RiverSR : Suwannee River Estual)'CH: C1:a.:;sillmwitzka River Estuary\\r;,V; Weeki Vv'achee RiverLargest #- of calves was 99 on January 13, 2010.Largest #- in "Cp. Homosassa \vas 153 on March 4, 20:0.Largest # i:J. Crystal River was 18 Oll Apr-il2S, 2010.1 State\\'idc Synoptic Manatee Aerial Survey.Information provided by U.S, Fish and Wildlife Service, Crystal River, FL

, C:::: :. '.,. I ,:. ,AERIAL IvLf .,"ATEE COVETS - 2009SeRVEY LOCATIONSTOTALpp Be WAC WIT SWRT (C)KB (;RY UHOM LHOM SR091.'1.,'109 324(28) 212(21) 470340XXX67(7)2lJPu"'\)09 1 46:(33) 248( : 6) 4(1) 156(8)00036(5) 00106FEB09 476(28) 296(16) 0124(9)X0056(3) 0XXXISFEB09 257(23) 110(15) 23470(6) 0XX43(2) 7(1)04MAR09 466(31) 285(18) 30058(4)XXX120(9)0ISMAR09 75( 7) 32( 2) 7(:)7(2)8(1) 20(:)XXX014(1 ) 19(1)30'L4Jt09 :24(11) 55( 6) 21 (2)636(1) XXX17APR09 133(10) SOC 6) 15(1 )XS(I)318(1) 72(1 ) XX5XXX30APR09 116(17) 5S( 9) 13(1)5(1) 14(4)0J3;V[AY09 101(19) 61(12) 9(1 )04(1)XXX8(2) 11 (2)3(')27.MAY09 CilIlce:lec.-no one to fly10JL'N0993(12) 59( 3) IX00XX10(1) 15(2) 324JUN0955(11) 36( 9) 4(1 )I23(1) XXX023S( 7)26( 4) 00XXXOSJUL094(2)0001022JUL0967( 8)31( 7) 26930004(1) 23(1) XXX05A1:G09 29( 5)11 ( 2) 4(1)52(1) 2219AUG09 73(16) 59(13) 16(2)XX0X03SEP09 65( 7)39( 4) 10(:)13(2)03XXX0016SEP09 5S( 9)45(8) 382(1) 000XXX30SEP09 46( 4)29( J) 6X5(1)0330XX22( 5) 3(1)140cr09 OS( 6)XXXJ00009(4) 27(:)XX290CT09 98(10)24( 3) 104(1)24(1) 0X110NOV09 55( 5)15( 2) 4(:)5(1) 25(1) 1XXX402DEC09 224(31) 120(20) 22(4)27(5) 3(1) 80:431XXX09DEC09 Cance11ec.-conflict with SHC r.:::.eeting16DEC09 Cance:leG c1oud ceiling too low23DEC09 438(42) 32S(33) 278(6) 0XX X030(3) 0DATEx; Ko SUl'"\.'eyT: Total of all manatees; aduJts calves(C): CalvesSUm.'TIgD':Higbest su.'V'ey count was 476o SREX0XXXXXXxXXXX0XXXXXXXXXCH \V'I}.,TXX5C) 11(2)XXXXXXXXXXXX20(2) x5X5(1) X7XS(I) X6(1) S0X1XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXFebruary 6,2009,Largest # in Kings Bay was 328 on December 23, 2009 .KB: Kings BEl)'CRY: Crysta RiverUHOI'vl: Upper Homosassa RiverLH01\-1: Lower Homosassa RiverLarge5t '# of calves was 42OJ:December 23, 2009.Lrgest # in Up. Homosassa was 156OIlJanUM): 21, 2009.SR: Salt RiverPP: CI)'stai River Nuclea, Power PlantDiscbarge CimaiV{AC; \Vaccasassa 3ay ar.d RiverLargest #- in Crystal River was 23 on February 18, 2009,\\TI: Withlacoochee RiverBe:S\VR:SRE:CH:Barge CanalS:l'\\'illlllee RiverSuwannee River Est.;.ary'Cbassahowitzka River Estuary\1,7\\,': \\'cC!k:i Wachee RiverI Statewide SY1:lop:ic Manatee Aerial Survey.Information provided by U.S, Fish and WilClife Service. Crystal River, FL

--AJlK1AL MA1'Al'EE COUNTS - 19,,!AR08TOTALSCRVEY LOCATIO»;STee)KB CRY UHOM LHOM SRPP BC WAC \\1T S\VR SRE CH WW365(29) 230(21) 10(1) 57(3)10(1) 29(1) 29(2) 0XXXXXXManatee sw,,.ey ,vas cancelled to accommodate a statewide synoptic s!.lrv'ey \\'hich also was cancelled.138(:6) 54( 7) 177(1)14(3) 21() 24(2) 1XXXXXX324(24) 216(22) 066(1)4038(1) 0XXXXXX245(18) 135(11) 1337(3)11(2) 445(2) 0XXXXXX106(11) 39(4) 11821(5) 2(1) 1312(:) XXXXXX07. \PROS (\0 flight.pl811eS no: availaole, 7.AFROS Xo flight-planes no: a'. .·ailaole.-?30APROS 142(18) 85(13) 619(4)17(1)14 !AY08 123(17)09(11) 1716(2)10(1)27'vL"YOS 113(22) 76(15) 6(2) 11(:)6IlJ1.,1\ OS Sun·ey cancellecwhigner priorities-FOIA.25JL'KOS54(11) 43(7) 5(1)10 o09JULOSSurvey cancelled-no one available23JULOS06AT.:G085S( 7) 34( 5) 120326( 3) 16( 2)';00Su:rv y cancelled-Tropical Stonn Fay.50(13) 26( 9) 6(3)0330( 7) 24(6)13(1)0S'J.rvey c2.t'.celled-mgmt. decisio:l60( 8) 41 (7)49(1)1230(24) 170(18) 5(:)21 (3)3(1)172(12) 41( 8) 26(1)443(41) 344(37) 376(3)389(29) 30:(26) 659(3)2167(27) 72(10) 20(3)13(2) 22(2)20AVG0803SEP0817SEP08010CTOS160CTOS3:0CTOS14 xX7(2)o7(2) XXXXXXX2(1)o3(2) 1)X3130(1)14(1) 019(1 ) 0210:4(3) XXXSUmn1 1Q':X; 1\0 SlIT'v'cyT: Total of all man,,:ees; ad'.:lts cdves(C): CalvesKB: Kings Buy'CRY: Crystal RiyerLl-IO:;'1; "Cpper Homosassa RiveI'LHOt-L Lower Homosassa RiverSR: Salt RiverPP: Cry'sta: River Kuc1ear Power PlantHighest survey count Vias 443 on XO'v'ember 26, 2008.Largest"# in Kings Bay was 344 on November 26, 2008.Largest # of calves was 37 on ovemocr 26, 2008.L2.:gest #- in Up. Homosassa was 76 ot'. November 26, 200S.Largest # ir, Crystal River was 20Discharg e Canal\\'AC: \Vaccasassa Bay and River\\'11': Withlacoochec RiverBe: Barge CanalSWR', Suwa:-tnee Ri'IJerSRE: S,",wannee River EstuaryCH; Chassa:'owitzka River EstuaryW\V; \\'eeki Wachee RiverI First Statew:de Synoptic Manatee Aerial Survey.Information p ovided by US. Fish and WilClife Serv1ce, C.rysml River. FL0.:".December 19, 200S,