Research PaperRegional Fellowship ProgramSituation Analysis of Access to HealthcareServices in Myanmar: Overview of MaternalHealthcareAuthorDirect SupervisorAssociate SupervisorEditor:Ms.Ei Ei Phyo Oo, Fellow from Myanmar:Dr. Kem Sothorn, Senior Instructor:Ms. Top Davy, Associate instructor:Mr. John Christopher, Director of InstitutionalDevelopment DepartmentDecember, 2018បរវេណព្រទ្ិឹ ធសភា េ ិមានរដ្ឋចំការមន មហាេ ិថីព្រះនវោត្តម ោជធានភ្ី នំវរញ �ជាSENATE Compound, Vimeanrath Chamkar Mon, Preah Norodom Blvd, Phnom Penh, Cambodia 023 210056 firstname.lastname@example.org www.pic.org.kh
Notice of DisclaimerThe Parliamentary Institute of Cambodia (PIC) is an independent parliamentary support institutionfor the clients Parliament which, upon request of the parliamentarians and the parliamentarycommissions, offers a wide range of training and research publications on current and emergingkey issues, legislation and major public policy topics. This research product is the outcome of a sixmonth’s parliamentary research fellowship program at PIC, during which the author studiedparliamentary research methods and applied what they learned to produce this paper. Theinformation in this product is likely to be relevant to parliamentary and constituency work but doesnot purport to represent or reflect the views of the Parliamentary Institute of Cambodia, theirclients Parliament or any of its members.The contents of this research paper, current at the date of publication, are for reference andinformation purposes only. This publication is not designed to provide legal or policy advice, and donot necessarily deal with every important topic or aspect of the issues it considers.The contents of this research paper are covered by applicable Cambodian laws and internationalcopyright agreements. Permission to reproduce in whole or in part or otherwise use the content onthis website may be sought from the appropriate source. 2019 Parliamentary Institute of Cambodia (PIC)
AcronymsANCAntenatal HealthcareASEANAssociation of South-east Asia NationsAus AIDAustralian AidHEFHealth equity FundJICAJapan International Cooperation AgencyMDGMillennium Development GoalsMDHSMyanmar Demographic Health SurveyMDSRMaternal Death Surveillance and ResponseMHCMaternal Health CareMMRMaternal Mortality RatioMWsMidwifesMoHSMinistry of health and SportsNHPNational Health PlanRHReproductive HealthRHCRural Health centersSDGsSustainable Development GoalsUNUNICEFUnited NationsUNFPAUnited Nations Population Assistant FundU5MRUnder five Mortality FateVHWVoluntary Health WorkerWHOWorld Health Organization3MDG FundThe three Millennium Development Goal FundUnited Nations International Children's Emergency Fund
Table of contentsList of Figures .5List of Tables .51. Introduction .12. The situation regarding maternal health .22.1 Current trends in maternal health . 22.2 Availability of maternal health services and workforce . 42.3 Accessibility and utilization of maternal health services . 72.4 Affordability of maternal health services . 113. Government policies and stakeholders contribution to maternal health programs .123.1. Institutional structure . 123.2 Government policy . 133.3 Maternal health financing . 143.4 Program coverage and focuses . 154. Conclusion .15Reference List .17
List of FiguresFigure 1: Trend in maternal mortality since 1990 (per 100,000 live births) .3Figure 2: Cause of death, by communicable diseases and maternal, prenatal and nutritionconditions (percentage of total).4Figure 3: Prevalence of anaemia among pregnant women (percent) .4Figure 4: Percentage of births attended by skilled health personnel .7Figure 5: Skilled assistance during delivery .7Figure 6: Percentage of women age 15-49 who had antenatal care coverage .8Figure 7: Institutional deliveries by states and regions .9List of TablesTable 1: Sector workers in Myanmar (2005-2015) .5Table 2: Women’s access to maternal health services by wealth quintile .11
1. IntroductionMyanmar is a Southeast Asian country with a low Human Development Index, reflecting the limitedaccess to quality health services and largely underdeveloped healthcare systems . By 2014, theMaternal Mortality Ratio (MMR) was 282 per 100,000 live births or 2,800 per year – the secondhighest among ASEAN countries [2, 3]. High MMR has been associated with limited access tocontraceptives and maternal health services and poor quality of health services for women [4, 5].Low or inadequate access to modern maternal health services were found particularly amongpoorer, less educated women from the rural households [6, pp.3-4, 7]. This highlights the inequalityin access to health services. Some studies also suggest that the lack of women’s empowerment infamily decision making, particularly on Reproductive Health (RH), financial resources allocation, aswell as the upholding of traditional norms (e.g. the man makes most the decisions) preventswomen from receiving adequate maternal healthcare services[6, 8, 9]Myanmar has adopted goal three of the Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) aimed at promotinghealth access and enhancing the quality of the services for citizens and SDG 5 for promoting genderequality and empowerment. The government and development partners have made significantefforts to improve the access to, and quality of health services. However, limited budget allocation,lack of healthcare workers, under provision of health facilities and poor health education remainlong-term challenges for equitable healthcare services [11, 12].This research paper aims to provide: (1) an overview of the general characteristics of the healthsector development in Myanmar, highlighting the issues and challenges in reproductive andmaternal health among women; and (2) a summary of policies and programs that are related toMaternal Health Care (MHC). Gender inequality and empowerment are the basis for the discussion.The key research questions are:1.What have been the trends and the present situation regarding maternal health inMyanmar?2.How has gender inequality, lack of women’s empowerment, and social norms hamperedthe ability of women in receiving maternal healthcare?What are the challenges indelivering effective and equitable maternal healthcare services?3.What have been the policies/programs of the government and stakeholders regardingmaternal healthcare?1 Page
This research is based entirely on available secondary documents and data. The information wascollected from journal articles, policy documents, and program implementation and evaluationreports. The quantitative outputs were extracted from Myanmar Demographic Health Survey(MDHS) 2015 and World Development Indicators and other available sources. The report consistsof four parts. The first section provides an overview and trends regarding maternal health inMyanmar. The second deals with the situation regarding maternal health focusing on three mainissues: (1) the availability of the services, (2) the accessibility and (3) the affordability. The third partfocuses on government policies and contributions of stakeholders to maternal healthcare. Sectionfour is the conclusion.1. The situation regarding maternal health2.1 Current trends in maternal healthImproving maternal health and child health services is the main priority of the National Health Plan(NHP) of Myanmar. The government has made a significant effort to promote overall reproductivehealth to reduce maternal mortality and improve the quality and accessibility of reproductivehealth services . The goal of SDGs 3 is to attain a better quality of life for people by improvingthe reproductive health status of women, men, adolescents, and youth . The Ministry of Healthand Sports is the key player in promoting and improving the health sector towards achieving theaim of “Health for all Goal” .Myanmar currently faces many challenges regarding its underdeveloped healthcare system. Thisincludes inadequate health of the workforce, poor physical infrastructure (e.g., inadequatehospitals), lack of healthcare equipment, and limited financial resources for this sector [15, 16]. Thehealth status among population is still poor compared to other countries in the region. Statistics in2010 showed that Myanmar had a total population of 51.9 million with average annual growth rateof 0.68 percent and by 2018, it is estimated to be 54million. Life expectancy is 64.7 years, thelowest among ASEAN countries . According to 2014 census, one of the most significant healthissues for the country is the high MMR. The country’s MMR is estimated the second highest amongASEAN countries, recorded at 282 deaths per 100,000 live births. Every year, approximately 2,800women die during pregnancy or childbirth . World Development Indicators 2018 estimatedthat, teenage mothers (age 15-19) accounted for 6 percent of total pregnant women.2 Page
Figure 1 shows the trend of Maternal Mortality deaths and the MMR since 1990. Since 1990, theMMR has dropped significantly, by more than half, from 450 deaths per 100,000 live births to 178deaths per 100,000 live births in 2015. The MMR varies by age, location, educational level andsocioeconomic group, which highlights the disparity in access to maternal healthcare by differentclusters of population . Similarly, the drop in MMR corresponds to the drop in the number ofmaternal deaths. The number of annual maternal deaths was 5,100 in 1990 and reduced by half in2006 before continuing to drop to 1,700 in 2015. However, the figure remains high whencompared to other countries in the region, meaning that to achieve the goal of SDG 5 the countryneeds to accelerate its efforts in promoting better healthcare systems.Figure 1: Trend in maternal mortality since 1990 (per 100,000 live births)50060004505000per 0Maternal mortality ratio (modeled estimate, per 100,000 live 9921991019900Number of maternal deathsSource: World Development Indicators 2017The causes of deaths by maternal, prenatal and malnutrition nutritional conditions andcommunicable diseases combined accounted for 24 percent of deaths throughout the country in2016 – this was a reduction from 45 percent in 2000 (Figure-2). Most maternal deaths are fromavoidable consequences during pregnancy and at childbirth and are largely preventable . Theleading direct cause of maternal deaths in 2010 was postpartum haemorrhage (31 percent),followed by hypertensive disorders during pregnancy (11 percent), and abortion-related causes (10percent) [9, 19]. The majority of women (62.7 percent) deliver at home which can be high risk forsome women as they lack medical treatment if difficulties arise. Not being able to reach healthfacilities on time was among the major causes of maternal deaths . This indicates the need forimprovements in delivery, antenatal and postnatal care which require the availability of better3 Page
skilled professionals within a reachable distance as well as the availability of medicines at anaffordable cost .A study in 2010 showed that only 38 percent of women with complications were referred to ahospital, and only 24 percent reached a hospital for proper healthcare services, while 14 percentdied on their way to the hospital due to long travel distances [20, p.93]. One of the main healthproblems in maternal death is caused by anaemia[21, p-240]. There are geographical disparities inanaemia prevalence and women in the coastal zone were more vulnerable to the disease [22, p112]. Figure 3 shows a worrisome picture in relation to anaemia among pregnant women. Despite aslight drop from 59.2 percent in 1990 to 44.6 in 2006, the number rises again to 53.8 percent in2016. Malnutrition and lack of education about maternal nutrition education was the main cause[23, p-966]Figure 2: Cause of death, by communicableFigure 3: Prevalence of anaemia amongdiseases and maternal, prenatal andpregnant women (percent)nutrition conditions (percentage of 45.444.646.740302010002000201020152016Source: World Development Indicators 20182.249.21990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2016Source: World Development Indicators 2018Availability of maternal health services and workforceStrengthening the community-based health care work force is essential for ensuring equity andaccess to basic healthcare services at the grass-roots level . In 2014, there were 1,056 publichospitals with 56,748 beds in total and the number of public health facilities in Myanmar consistingof 87 primaryi and secondary health centreii, 348 maternal and child health centres, and 1,684 ruraliPrimary healthcare center refer to Primary level Facilities/Hospitals (Sub-Centre, Rural Health Center,Maternal and Child Health Center (MCH) and Urban Health Center)iiSecondary healthcare center is defined as station or Township Hospital without Obstetrics andGynecology (ObGy) Specialist)4 Page
health centres. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) health statistics, in 2013–2014the number of doctors, nurses and midwives, and dental surgeons per 100,000 people in Myanmarwas 61, 100, and 7 respectively, while in South-East Asia as a whole there, there were 59, 153, and10, respectively . Given the lack of health workers, maternal healthcare related activities,especially in rural areas, are carried out by midwives. Midwifes and Lady Health Visitors were themain service providers for maternal and reproductive health at the grass roots level .Basic Health Staff are the main health providers for rural area. There are community-based healthworkers in charge of providing some basic healthcare services. Midwifes are basic health staffproviding basic health services for families at the community level . Midwifes have to takeresponsibility for maternal and child healthcare as well as immunization, nutrition promotion anddisease control activities in their respective communities. Due to the heavy work load, midwivescannot prioritize their activities so maternal and child healthcare activities are affected to someextent. There are 64,134 villages in Myanmar and having one health staff per village has not yetbeen achieved. Community health care volunteers are one component of the health careworkforce and some health activities including maternal healthcare, still rely on them especially inemergency situations . Lack of healthcare workers significantly impeded progress toward therealization of health-related Millennium Development Goals and SDGs .The number ofhealthcare workers in Myanmar is shown in Table (1).Table 1: Sector workers in Myanmar 258Lady Health Visitor3,0253,3443,3713,3973,4673,578Indigenous Medical8198908858751,0481,033(i) State Service(ii) Private PracticeHealth Assistant5 Page
Source: Healthcare Guide 2018In relation to healthcare, the country’s common issues include: (1) inadequacy of healthinfrastructure, (2) lack of human resources, particularly in remote areas, and conflict-affectedareas; and (3) poor communications and infrastructure especially in Chin state and Ayeyarwaddy.All of these barriers prevent communities, particularly in rural and remote areas, from properlyreceiving or accessing health information, health education, and services. Poor roads andchallenging weather conditions, reduce the ability of healthcare providers to access people inremote areas.Wide geographic, ethnic and socio-economic disparities are among the challenges in deliveringhealthcare services. Ethnic minorities and people in remote areas, such as in Mon and ChinStates, expressed their concerns that there were not adequately trained healthcare workers and alack of healthcare facilities to addresscommon illnesses and health needs of theircommunities. The lack of trained health staff and health facilities is the leading cause of highMMRs and Under Five Maternal death Rate (U5MR) in these remote states.By 2016, there were 1.33 healthcare workers (doctors, nurses and midwifes) per 1,000 people(MoHS), well below the WHO minimum recommended threshold of 2.3. In terms of distribution,health workers were largely concentrated in urban areas, including Yangon and Mandalay. Theproportion of births attended by skilled personnel increased from 56 percent average in 1997 to 78percent in 2010 . These indicators show some differences in achievements between rural andurban areas.Figure 4 shows the percentage of births attended by skilled staff from 2000 to 2015. About half oftotal births were assisted by skilled health staff in 2000. The situation has been progressivelyimproved and by 2015, around 80 percent of births had support from skilled staff. Figure 5 providesdetails in relation to having skilled staff attending during deliveries in 2014. Three-fifths of birthsare assisted by skilled providers (60 percent) that includes nurses, midwives, and doctors. It isnotable that almost one in three births are still assisted by traditional birth attendants .6 Page
3.37055.38064.1Figure 4: Percentage of births attended by skilled health 5200420032002200120000YearSource: Health Management Information SystemFigure 5: Skilled assistance during deliveryAuxiliaryRealative/midwifefriend 6%4%Doctor32%Traditionalbirthattendant29%No one1%Nurse/midwife/[PERCENTAGE]Source: Demographic Health Survey 2015-20162.3 Accessibility and utilization of maternal health servicesThe latest data from Myanmar Demographic and Health Survey (2015-2016) indicates that,approximately one in 200 women in the country died from pregnancy complications or childbearing. The ability of women to access timely healthcare services during pregnancy (Antenatal care),delivery and postnatal, is vital given that the majority of the population require such services duringtheir child bearing years . The perceived problems in accessing healthcare services includingmaternal healthcare are: (1) lack of finances to pay for services, (2) patients not wanting to travelalone to receive healthcare (3) health facilities being too far to reach and (4) lack of modern healthservices [18, 29].7 Page
Figure 6 shows the percentage of women who had access to antenatal care coverage in 2015. Thesurvey reveals that 81 percent of women aged 15-49 received at least one antennal care sessionwith skilled providers during their pregnancy for their most recent birth. Of women who live inurban areas, 84 percent have at least four ANC (Antenatal Healthcare) visits compared to 51percent for those in rural areas. The lowest access to ANC was found in Shan (below 70 percent)and Rakhine States (71.1 percent). It is worth noting that access to ANC is positively associated withthe education level of women (i.e., the higher the education level the more likely the woman willaccess healthcare) [30, p-129]. Additionally, women in urban areas have wider access to ANC, dueto the availability of services within their reach[14, 18]. There is a gap regarding access tovaccinations; 81 percent of women in urban areas versus 69 percent of those in rural areas canaccess this service.Figure 6: Percentage of women age 15-49 who had antenatal care coverage10090Percentages807060Received any ANC from askilled provider50Had 4 ANC visits40Had ANC in first trimester ( 4months)3020100TotalUrbanRuralSource: Demographic Health Survey 2015-2016Three quarters of all maternal deaths occur during delivery and in the immediate post-partumperiod  Getting to appropriate health facilities remains a big challenge for many people living inrural and remote areas. Hence, home delivery is still common at these locations . The 20152016 MDHS indicates that only 37 percent of live births take place in a health facility and 60percent of these births are delivered by skilled providers . There is inequality in access toservices between rural and urban areas with only one in five women from rural areas able to accessservices versus 70 percent for urban dwelling women.8 Page
Figure 7 presents a map on institutional deliveries by state. It shows that cities like Yangon have thehighest accessibility rate (65 percent). In other states, institutional deliveries vary between 30-40percent. In most remote states such as Chin, the institutional delivery rate was as low as 14percent. The possible causes are that the areas in conflict zones and the transportation systems arepoor, preventing people from accessing health services. This means efforts to improve maternalhealthcare systems should be prioritised in such states. The survey confirmed that the higher thewomen’s education the more likely they are to access institutional delivery services .Figure 7: Institutional deliveries by states and regionsSource: Demographic Health Survey 2015-2016Women who deliver in a health facility are more likely to receive a postnatal check-up than thosewho deliver elsewhere. According to 2015-2016 DHS, 71 percent of mothers and 36 percent ofnewborns receive postnatal check-ups within the first two days after birth. Women in urban areasreceive more postnatal check-ups than women in rural areas with the incidence in Chin Stateremaining the lowest (21 percent) and the Magway region being the highest (92 percent) .9 Page
A number of studies found that poverty and remoteness were not the only factors that hamperwomen’s access to maternal health services. Lack of women’s empowerment through pooreducation, ethnicity and religious diversity, linguistic limitations, cultural and gender norms arealso found to have an impact on women’s ability to access maternal healthcare services, which inturn can have a negative effect on their health outcomes[10, 15, 18].Lack of women’s empowerment is found to be associated with lower access to health services forwomen across the states. Lack of education may also lead to earlier marriages resulting inunwanted pregnancies and births, illiteracy which limits health awareness, reduced ability tounderstand the cause of ill health, and lack of awareness of when and where to seekhealthcare.The country is a multicultural society with extensive cultural, linguistic, and religious diversity. Thecountry has about 135 ethnic groups and thus different cultural practices and languages arepresent. There is also a widespread belief across the country and among different religious andethnic groups that differential treatment of men and women originates in religious texts. Forexample, the high prevalence of traditional birth practices among ethnic women in rural andremote areas reflects both the unavailability of modern healthcare services and their preferencefor the use of traditional over modern delivery practices. Traditional beliefs and practices regardingpregnancy and childbirth are passed down inter-generationally from mothers and mothers-in-lawto daughters and daughters-in-law. Lack of education and knowledge could be a contributingfactor to these decisions.Cultural norms that position women as inferior in the household impact women’s opportunitiesfor a healthy life and limit their choices for their maternal health and family planning . Gendernorms, in particular, tend to describe women’s bodies as dirty or shameful, and equatewomen’s health concerns with reproductioniii. These norms can lead to limited access to sexualand reproductive health and proper access to healthcare; justification of men’s violenceiiiReproductive health is “a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely theabsence of disease or infirmity, in all matters relating to the reproductive system and to its functions andprocesses“ 34. World Health Organization. (n.d). Reproductive Health [Online]. World Health Organization.Available at: http://www.wpro.who.int/topics/reproductive health/en/ [Accessed 5 Sep. 2018].10 P a g e
against women, including sexual violence; and allegations that women fail to conform to culturalnorms.2.4 Affordability of maternal health servicesSocioeconomic barriers, poverty, and limited access to public healthcare force many households torely on for-profit healthcare providers which are frequently overpriced and of poor quality .Access to private health services is barely affordable for those who live below the poverty line. In2015, the country poverty rate was 32 percent where 38.8 percent of the rural population areestimated to be poor compared to 14.5 percent of those in its towns and cities . The povertyrate is twice as high in remote and hard-to-reach areas. Household economic status significantlyimpacts affordability of maternal health services .Table 2 summarises the access to maternal healthcare services by women from differentsocioeconomic groups. The incidence of receiving ANC across Myanmar was 67 to 98 percent,varying between the lowest to highest quintile. The coverage for vaccinations against neonataltetanus was slightly above 62 percent for the lowest wealth quintile group compare to 81 percentfor the highest quintile group. The data is more staggered when it comes to access to institutionaldeliveries. Home delivery is common for women from the lowest quintile group (more than 80percent), particularly in remote rural areas. The incidence of deliveries in health institutions variesbetween 25 and 50 percent among the second, middle and fourth quintile. However, access toinstitutional delivery is more common among women with at least secondary education (83percent). While the deliveries assisted by skilled providers help ensure safe and clean delivery, lessthan 40 percent of the women from the lowest, and half from the second quintile can afford theservices. The fourth quintile had the highest incidence of receiving postnatal check-up (89 percent),followed by the middle quintile (77.1 percent). About half of women from the lowest wealthquintile had received the services.Table 2: Women’s access to maternal health services by wealth quintileIndicator NamesLowest11 P a g e2015Second Middle Fourth Highest
Percentage receiving antenatal care from a skilledprovider (ANC)Percentage whose last birth was protected againstneonatal tetanusPercentage receiving deliveries in a health facilityPercentage of deliveries by a skilled providerPercentage of women with a postnatal checkup inthe first two days after 071.2Source: Myanmar Demographic and Health Survey 2015-2016Financial constraints and poverty are the major factors limiting the access to maternal healthcareservices. Women from high poverty, coastaliv and mountainous areasv have lower access to healthservices than in other states . Additionally one study shows health expenditures are one reasonpoor households fall into poverty .Affordability of health services is also determined by women’s participation in household decisionmaking. Their participation in household decision making is an important factor in women’s abilityto have control over their lives or to allocate household financial resources for her healthcare (e.g.,for ANC visits, birth delivery and postnatal care and the use of contraceptives to control unwantedbirths). According to 2015-2016 DHS, 65 percent of married women participate in decisions inthree specific areas (i.e. women’s own healthcare, major household purchases, and visits to theirfamily or relatives).
1. The situation regarding maternal health 2.1 Current trends in maternal health Improving maternal health and child health services is the main priority of the National Health Plan (NHP) of Myanmar. The government has made a significant effort to promote overall reproductive health to reduce maternal mortality and improve the quality and .
Myanmar language. · Moreover, it translated laws into English and published in three volumes as "Myanmar Laws( 1988-1989)", "Myanmar Laws( 1997)" and "Myanmar Laws( 1998-1999)". This issue "Myanmar Laws(2000)" is the·con inuation of the publication mentioned above. "Myanmar Laws(1990)"
PwC Myanmar is located at: PricewaterhouseCoopers Myanmar Co., Ltd Room 9A, 9th Floor, Centrepoint Towers, No. 65, Corner of Sule Pagoda Road and Merchant Road, Kyauktada Township, Yangon, Myanmar Jovi Seet Senior Executive Director PwC Myanmar Office: 959 440230 341 email@example.com Jasmine Thazin Aung Director PwC Myanmar Mobile: 959 .
square miles, Myanmar is the largest country in mainland Southeast Asia. The stunning Shwedagon Pagoda is said to house strands of Buddha's hair and many other holy relics. There are more than 10,000 Buddhist temples, pagodas, and monasteries in the Mandalay region of Myanmar. Myanmar 8 Teach English in Myanmar premiertefi.com
2.5 High School English Teacher Academic Qualification 34 2.6 The role of English Teaching in Myanmar 39 2.6.1 Current view on English in Myanmar 39 2.6.2 Myanmar EFL Teaching and Learning Situation 40 2.7 Overview of English Teaching Problems 42 Chapter III: Research Methodology 48 3.1 Participants 48
Myanmar highly vulnerable to the negative impacts of climate change. Myanmar’s next election is scheduled for 2015, and the emerging leaders have the opportunity to make significant progress in climate change adaptation. Cooperation between Myanmar’s new leaders and the international community could accelerate the nation’s
Separately, the Asian Development Bank projects Myanmar’s GDP growth at 6.5% in 2013, rising to 6.7% in 2014. Growth is expected to be bolstered by the European Union’s reinstatement of preferential access for Myanmar’s exports and the United States’ suspension of its ban on imports from Myanmar.
Myanmar 3 Key Facts Maternal and Newborn Health Disparities in Myanmar In 2015, 940,000 babies were born in Myanmar, or around 2,600 every day.1 5 percent of adolescent girls (aged 15-19) have had a live birth.* Approximately 67 babies will die each day before reaching their first month3;
Myanmar military and the state more broadly, Myanmar’s longstanding hostility toward and fear of foreign domination, the fragile and sometimes hostile relations between the state and some of Myanmar’s ethnic groups, and the large and increasing role that China and Chinese prod